The Challenges of Adapting a Questionnaire to a New Cultural Context: The Case of Studying Group-Based Guilt and Shame in Russia

• Main Authors: Grigoryan L.K., Khaptsova A.A., Poluektova O.V.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Moscow State University of Psychology and Education 2018-10-01
• Series: Культурно-историческая психология
• Subjects: methodology of psychology; questionnaire adaptation; cultural sensitivity; group-based emotions; guilt
• Online Access: http://psyjournals.ru/en/kip/2018/n1/Crigoryan_Khaptsova_Poluektova.shtml
• ISSN: 1816-5435; 2224-8935

With the majority of social-psychological research still being conducted in Western countries, researchers from non-Western countries often adopt existing theories, constructs, and instruments that are not necessarily applicable to the contexts they are interested in. This paper discusses problems that might arise when transferring psychological constructs and instruments from one cultural setting to another. We use the case of a study of group-based guilt and shame in Russia that was carried out by the research team. First, we briefly discuss the original study and the problems we encountered while conducting it. We then analyze the results of eight in-depth semi-structured interviews that followed up the original study. Finally, we conduct a thematic analysis of Facebook commentaries (N=98) that participants left after filling out the original questionnaire. Based on these analyses, we suggest a checklist for researchers who plan to study a psychological construct that wasn’t studied in a given cultural context before. With this paper, we hope to highlight the importance of thorough and comprehensive adaptation of psychological constructs and instruments to new cultural settings.