A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19

Abstract The role of meteorological and air quality factors in moderating the transmission of SARS‐CoV‐2 and severity of COVID‐19 is a critical topic as an opportunity for targeted intervention and relevant public health messaging. Studies conducted in early 2020 suggested that temperature, humidity...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Amanda V. Quintana, Meredith Clemons, Krista Hoevemeyer, Ann Liu, John Balbus
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: American Geophysical Union (AGU) 2021-07-01
Series:GeoHealth
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1029/2020GH000367
id doaj-7bba946c0ddc4956b996b15c974e60dd
record_format Article
spelling doaj-7bba946c0ddc4956b996b15c974e60dd2021-08-03T08:56:11ZengAmerican Geophysical Union (AGU)GeoHealth2471-14032021-07-0157n/an/a10.1029/2020GH000367A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19Amanda V. Quintana0Meredith Clemons1Krista Hoevemeyer2Ann Liu3John Balbus4ICF International ‐ U.S. Global Change Research Program Washington DC USAGeorge Washington University Washington DC USADes Moines University ‐ U.S. Global Change Research Program Des Moines IA USANational Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Bethesda MD USANational Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Bethesda MD USAAbstract The role of meteorological and air quality factors in moderating the transmission of SARS‐CoV‐2 and severity of COVID‐19 is a critical topic as an opportunity for targeted intervention and relevant public health messaging. Studies conducted in early 2020 suggested that temperature, humidity, ultraviolet radiation, and other meteorological factors have an influence on the transmissibility and viral dynamics of COVID‐19. Previous reviews of the literature have found significant heterogeneity in associations but did not examine many factors relating to epidemiological quality of the analyses such as rigor of data collection and statistical analysis, or consideration of potential confounding factors. To provide greater insight into the current state of the literature from an epidemiological standpoint, the authors conducted a rapid descriptive analysis with a strong focus on the characterization of COVID‐19 health outcomes and use of controls for confounding social and demographic variables such as population movement and age. We have found that few studies adequately considered the challenges posed by the use of governmental reporting of laboratory testing as a proxy for disease transmission, including timeliness and consistency. In addition, very few studies attempted to control for confounding factors, including timing and implementation of public health interventions and metrics of population compliance with those interventions. Ongoing research should give greater consideration to the measures used to quantify COVID‐19 transmission and health outcomes as well as how to control for the confounding influences of public health measures and personal behaviors.https://doi.org/10.1029/2020GH000367climateweatherpublic healthCOVID‐19
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Amanda V. Quintana
Meredith Clemons
Krista Hoevemeyer
Ann Liu
John Balbus
spellingShingle Amanda V. Quintana
Meredith Clemons
Krista Hoevemeyer
Ann Liu
John Balbus
A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19
GeoHealth
climate
weather
public health
COVID‐19
author_facet Amanda V. Quintana
Meredith Clemons
Krista Hoevemeyer
Ann Liu
John Balbus
author_sort Amanda V. Quintana
title A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19
title_short A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19
title_full A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19
title_fullStr A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19
title_full_unstemmed A Descriptive Analysis of the Scientific Literature on Meteorological and Air Quality Factors and COVID‐19
title_sort descriptive analysis of the scientific literature on meteorological and air quality factors and covid‐19
publisher American Geophysical Union (AGU)
series GeoHealth
issn 2471-1403
publishDate 2021-07-01
description Abstract The role of meteorological and air quality factors in moderating the transmission of SARS‐CoV‐2 and severity of COVID‐19 is a critical topic as an opportunity for targeted intervention and relevant public health messaging. Studies conducted in early 2020 suggested that temperature, humidity, ultraviolet radiation, and other meteorological factors have an influence on the transmissibility and viral dynamics of COVID‐19. Previous reviews of the literature have found significant heterogeneity in associations but did not examine many factors relating to epidemiological quality of the analyses such as rigor of data collection and statistical analysis, or consideration of potential confounding factors. To provide greater insight into the current state of the literature from an epidemiological standpoint, the authors conducted a rapid descriptive analysis with a strong focus on the characterization of COVID‐19 health outcomes and use of controls for confounding social and demographic variables such as population movement and age. We have found that few studies adequately considered the challenges posed by the use of governmental reporting of laboratory testing as a proxy for disease transmission, including timeliness and consistency. In addition, very few studies attempted to control for confounding factors, including timing and implementation of public health interventions and metrics of population compliance with those interventions. Ongoing research should give greater consideration to the measures used to quantify COVID‐19 transmission and health outcomes as well as how to control for the confounding influences of public health measures and personal behaviors.
topic climate
weather
public health
COVID‐19
url https://doi.org/10.1029/2020GH000367
work_keys_str_mv AT amandavquintana adescriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT meredithclemons adescriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT kristahoevemeyer adescriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT annliu adescriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT johnbalbus adescriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT amandavquintana descriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT meredithclemons descriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT kristahoevemeyer descriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT annliu descriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
AT johnbalbus descriptiveanalysisofthescientificliteratureonmeteorologicalandairqualityfactorsandcovid19
_version_ 1721223461689360384