Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization.
Participants aged 5;2-6;8, 9;2-10;6 and 18;1-22;2 (72 at each age) rated verb argument structure overgeneralization errors (e.g., *Daddy giggled the baby) using a five-point scale. The study was designed to investigate the feasibility of two proposed construction-general solutions to the question of...
Main Authors: | , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Public Library of Science (PLoS)
2014-01-01
|
Series: | PLoS ONE |
Online Access: | http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4412412?pdf=render |
id |
doaj-7b079cc428394ec1841f14e63d8a84bd |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-7b079cc428394ec1841f14e63d8a84bd2020-11-24T21:11:03ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032014-01-01104e012372310.1371/journal.pone.0123723Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization.Ben AmbridgeAmy BidgoodKatherine E TwomeyJulian M PineCaroline F RowlandDaniel FreudenthalParticipants aged 5;2-6;8, 9;2-10;6 and 18;1-22;2 (72 at each age) rated verb argument structure overgeneralization errors (e.g., *Daddy giggled the baby) using a five-point scale. The study was designed to investigate the feasibility of two proposed construction-general solutions to the question of how children retreat from, or avoid, such errors. No support was found for the prediction of the preemption hypothesis that the greater the frequency of the verb in the single most nearly synonymous construction (for this example, the periphrastic causative; e.g., Daddy made the baby giggle), the lower the acceptability of the error. Support was found, however, for the prediction of the entrenchment hypothesis that the greater the overall frequency of the verb, regardless of construction, the lower the acceptability of the error, at least for the two older groups. Thus while entrenchment appears to be a robust solution to the problem of the retreat from error, and one that generalizes across different error types, we did not find evidence that this is the case for preemption. The implication is that the solution to the retreat from error lies not with specialized mechanisms, but rather in a probabilistic process of construction competition.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4412412?pdf=render |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Ben Ambridge Amy Bidgood Katherine E Twomey Julian M Pine Caroline F Rowland Daniel Freudenthal |
spellingShingle |
Ben Ambridge Amy Bidgood Katherine E Twomey Julian M Pine Caroline F Rowland Daniel Freudenthal Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization. PLoS ONE |
author_facet |
Ben Ambridge Amy Bidgood Katherine E Twomey Julian M Pine Caroline F Rowland Daniel Freudenthal |
author_sort |
Ben Ambridge |
title |
Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization. |
title_short |
Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization. |
title_full |
Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization. |
title_fullStr |
Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization. |
title_full_unstemmed |
Preemption versus Entrenchment: Towards a Construction-General Solution to the Problem of the Retreat from Verb Argument Structure Overgeneralization. |
title_sort |
preemption versus entrenchment: towards a construction-general solution to the problem of the retreat from verb argument structure overgeneralization. |
publisher |
Public Library of Science (PLoS) |
series |
PLoS ONE |
issn |
1932-6203 |
publishDate |
2014-01-01 |
description |
Participants aged 5;2-6;8, 9;2-10;6 and 18;1-22;2 (72 at each age) rated verb argument structure overgeneralization errors (e.g., *Daddy giggled the baby) using a five-point scale. The study was designed to investigate the feasibility of two proposed construction-general solutions to the question of how children retreat from, or avoid, such errors. No support was found for the prediction of the preemption hypothesis that the greater the frequency of the verb in the single most nearly synonymous construction (for this example, the periphrastic causative; e.g., Daddy made the baby giggle), the lower the acceptability of the error. Support was found, however, for the prediction of the entrenchment hypothesis that the greater the overall frequency of the verb, regardless of construction, the lower the acceptability of the error, at least for the two older groups. Thus while entrenchment appears to be a robust solution to the problem of the retreat from error, and one that generalizes across different error types, we did not find evidence that this is the case for preemption. The implication is that the solution to the retreat from error lies not with specialized mechanisms, but rather in a probabilistic process of construction competition. |
url |
http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4412412?pdf=render |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT benambridge preemptionversusentrenchmenttowardsaconstructiongeneralsolutiontotheproblemoftheretreatfromverbargumentstructureovergeneralization AT amybidgood preemptionversusentrenchmenttowardsaconstructiongeneralsolutiontotheproblemoftheretreatfromverbargumentstructureovergeneralization AT katherineetwomey preemptionversusentrenchmenttowardsaconstructiongeneralsolutiontotheproblemoftheretreatfromverbargumentstructureovergeneralization AT julianmpine preemptionversusentrenchmenttowardsaconstructiongeneralsolutiontotheproblemoftheretreatfromverbargumentstructureovergeneralization AT carolinefrowland preemptionversusentrenchmenttowardsaconstructiongeneralsolutiontotheproblemoftheretreatfromverbargumentstructureovergeneralization AT danielfreudenthal preemptionversusentrenchmenttowardsaconstructiongeneralsolutiontotheproblemoftheretreatfromverbargumentstructureovergeneralization |
_version_ |
1716754701788119040 |