Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at Presentation

Background: The COVID-19 global pandemic has posed unprecedented challenges to health care systems all over the world. The speed of the viral spread results in a tsunami of patients, which begs for a reliable screening tool using readily available data to predict disease progression.Methods: Multice...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Yuexing Tu, Xianlong Zhou, Lina Shao, Jiayin Zheng, Jiafeng Wang, Yixin Wang, Weiwei Tong, Mingshan Wang, Jia Wu, Junpeng Zhu, Rong Yan, Yemin Ji, Legao Chen, Di Zhu, Huafang Wang, Sheng Chen, Renyang Liu, Jingyang Lin, Jun Zhang, Haijun Huang, Yan Zhao, Minghua Ge
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Frontiers Media S.A. 2021-05-01
Series:Frontiers in Public Health
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.610280/full
id doaj-73b9cac6924d43d196251a9e594b6db7
record_format Article
spelling doaj-73b9cac6924d43d196251a9e594b6db72021-05-11T04:37:00ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Public Health2296-25652021-05-01910.3389/fpubh.2021.610280610280Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at PresentationYuexing Tu0Xianlong Zhou1Lina Shao2Jiayin Zheng3Jiafeng Wang4Yixin Wang5Weiwei Tong6Mingshan Wang7Jia Wu8Junpeng Zhu9Rong Yan10Yemin Ji11Legao Chen12Di Zhu13Huafang Wang14Sheng Chen15Renyang Liu16Jingyang Lin17Jun Zhang18Haijun Huang19Yan Zhao20Minghua Ge21Zhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhongnan Hospital, Wuhan University, Wuhan, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaFred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA, United StatesZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaFred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA, United StatesGennlife (Beijing) Technology Co. Ltd., Beijing, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaZhongnan Hospital, Wuhan University, Wuhan, ChinaZhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, ChinaBackground: The COVID-19 global pandemic has posed unprecedented challenges to health care systems all over the world. The speed of the viral spread results in a tsunami of patients, which begs for a reliable screening tool using readily available data to predict disease progression.Methods: Multicenter retrospective cohort study was performed to develop and validate a triage model. Patient demographic and non-laboratory clinical data were recorded. Using only the data from Zhongnan Hospital, step-wise multivariable logistic regression was performed, and a prognostic nomogram was constructed based on the independent variables identifies. The discrimination and calibration of the model were validated. External independent validation was performed to further address the utility of this model using data from Jinyintan Hospital.Results: A total of 716 confirmed COVID-19 cases from Zhongnan Hospital were included for model construction. Men, increased age, fever, hypertension, cardio-cerebrovascular disease, dyspnea, cough, and myalgia are independent risk factors for disease progression. External independent validation was carried out in a cohort with 201 cases from Jinyintan Hospital. The area under the curve (AUC) was 0.787 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.747–0.827) in the training group and 0.704 (95% CI: 0.632–0.777) in the validation group.Conclusions: We developed a novel triage model based on basic and clinical data. Our model could be used as a pragmatic screening aid to allow for cost efficient screening to be carried out such as over the phone, which may reduce disease propagation through limiting unnecessary contact. This may help allocation of limited medical resources.https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.610280/fullCOVID-19pandemicrisk factornomogramtriage
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Yuexing Tu
Xianlong Zhou
Lina Shao
Jiayin Zheng
Jiafeng Wang
Yixin Wang
Weiwei Tong
Mingshan Wang
Jia Wu
Junpeng Zhu
Rong Yan
Yemin Ji
Legao Chen
Di Zhu
Huafang Wang
Sheng Chen
Renyang Liu
Jingyang Lin
Jun Zhang
Haijun Huang
Yan Zhao
Minghua Ge
spellingShingle Yuexing Tu
Xianlong Zhou
Lina Shao
Jiayin Zheng
Jiafeng Wang
Yixin Wang
Weiwei Tong
Mingshan Wang
Jia Wu
Junpeng Zhu
Rong Yan
Yemin Ji
Legao Chen
Di Zhu
Huafang Wang
Sheng Chen
Renyang Liu
Jingyang Lin
Jun Zhang
Haijun Huang
Yan Zhao
Minghua Ge
Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at Presentation
Frontiers in Public Health
COVID-19
pandemic
risk factor
nomogram
triage
author_facet Yuexing Tu
Xianlong Zhou
Lina Shao
Jiayin Zheng
Jiafeng Wang
Yixin Wang
Weiwei Tong
Mingshan Wang
Jia Wu
Junpeng Zhu
Rong Yan
Yemin Ji
Legao Chen
Di Zhu
Huafang Wang
Sheng Chen
Renyang Liu
Jingyang Lin
Jun Zhang
Haijun Huang
Yan Zhao
Minghua Ge
author_sort Yuexing Tu
title Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at Presentation
title_short Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at Presentation
title_full Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at Presentation
title_fullStr Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at Presentation
title_full_unstemmed Predicting Progression of COVID-19 Infection to Prioritize Medical Resource Allocation: A Novel Triage Model Based on Patient Characteristics and Symptoms at Presentation
title_sort predicting progression of covid-19 infection to prioritize medical resource allocation: a novel triage model based on patient characteristics and symptoms at presentation
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
series Frontiers in Public Health
issn 2296-2565
publishDate 2021-05-01
description Background: The COVID-19 global pandemic has posed unprecedented challenges to health care systems all over the world. The speed of the viral spread results in a tsunami of patients, which begs for a reliable screening tool using readily available data to predict disease progression.Methods: Multicenter retrospective cohort study was performed to develop and validate a triage model. Patient demographic and non-laboratory clinical data were recorded. Using only the data from Zhongnan Hospital, step-wise multivariable logistic regression was performed, and a prognostic nomogram was constructed based on the independent variables identifies. The discrimination and calibration of the model were validated. External independent validation was performed to further address the utility of this model using data from Jinyintan Hospital.Results: A total of 716 confirmed COVID-19 cases from Zhongnan Hospital were included for model construction. Men, increased age, fever, hypertension, cardio-cerebrovascular disease, dyspnea, cough, and myalgia are independent risk factors for disease progression. External independent validation was carried out in a cohort with 201 cases from Jinyintan Hospital. The area under the curve (AUC) was 0.787 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.747–0.827) in the training group and 0.704 (95% CI: 0.632–0.777) in the validation group.Conclusions: We developed a novel triage model based on basic and clinical data. Our model could be used as a pragmatic screening aid to allow for cost efficient screening to be carried out such as over the phone, which may reduce disease propagation through limiting unnecessary contact. This may help allocation of limited medical resources.
topic COVID-19
pandemic
risk factor
nomogram
triage
url https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.610280/full
work_keys_str_mv AT yuexingtu predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT xianlongzhou predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT linashao predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT jiayinzheng predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT jiafengwang predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT yixinwang predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT weiweitong predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT mingshanwang predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT jiawu predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT junpengzhu predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT rongyan predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT yeminji predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT legaochen predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT dizhu predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT huafangwang predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT shengchen predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT renyangliu predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT jingyanglin predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT junzhang predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT haijunhuang predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT yanzhao predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
AT minghuage predictingprogressionofcovid19infectiontoprioritizemedicalresourceallocationanoveltriagemodelbasedonpatientcharacteristicsandsymptomsatpresentation
_version_ 1721453035679383552