A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-study

Local path planning is important in the development of autonomous vehicles since it allows a vehicle to adapt their movements to dynamic environments, for instance, when obstacles are detected. This work presents an evaluation of the performance of different local path planning techniques for an Aut...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Federico Peralta, Mario Arzamendia, Derlis Gregor, Daniel G. Reina, Sergio Toral
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-03-01
Series:Sensors
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/20/5/1488
id doaj-6638d9e2328e4bb98d62d305d4680588
record_format Article
spelling doaj-6638d9e2328e4bb98d62d305d46805882020-11-25T02:24:31ZengMDPI AGSensors1424-82202020-03-01205148810.3390/s20051488s20051488A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-studyFederico Peralta0Mario Arzamendia1Derlis Gregor2Daniel G. Reina3Sergio Toral4Facultad de Ingeniería, Universidad Nacional de Asunción, 2160 San Lorenzo, ParaguayFacultad de Ingeniería, Universidad Nacional de Asunción, 2160 San Lorenzo, ParaguayFacultad de Ingeniería, Universidad Nacional de Asunción, 2160 San Lorenzo, ParaguayUniversidad de Sevilla, 41004 Sevilla, EspanaUniversidad de Sevilla, 41004 Sevilla, EspanaLocal path planning is important in the development of autonomous vehicles since it allows a vehicle to adapt their movements to dynamic environments, for instance, when obstacles are detected. This work presents an evaluation of the performance of different local path planning techniques for an Autonomous Surface Vehicle, using a custom-made simulator based on the open-source Robotarium framework. The conducted simulations allow to verify, compare and visualize the solutions of the different techniques. The selected techniques for evaluation include A*, Potential Fields (PF), Rapidly-Exploring Random Trees* (RRT*) and variations of the Fast Marching Method (FMM), along with a proposed new method called Updating the Fast Marching Square method (uFMS). The evaluation proposed in this work includes ways to summarize time and safety measures for local path planning techniques. The results in a Lake environment present the advantages and disadvantages of using each technique. The proposed uFMS and A* have been shown to achieve interesting performance in terms of processing time, distance travelled and security levels. Furthermore, the proposed uFMS algorithm is capable of generating smoother routes.https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/20/5/1488autonomous surface vehiclelocal path planningmonitoring applicationsmotion planningypacarai lake
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Federico Peralta
Mario Arzamendia
Derlis Gregor
Daniel G. Reina
Sergio Toral
spellingShingle Federico Peralta
Mario Arzamendia
Derlis Gregor
Daniel G. Reina
Sergio Toral
A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-study
Sensors
autonomous surface vehicle
local path planning
monitoring applications
motion planning
ypacarai lake
author_facet Federico Peralta
Mario Arzamendia
Derlis Gregor
Daniel G. Reina
Sergio Toral
author_sort Federico Peralta
title A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-study
title_short A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-study
title_full A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-study
title_fullStr A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-study
title_full_unstemmed A Comparison of Local Path Planning Techniques of Autonomous Surface Vehicles for Monitoring Applications: The Ypacarai Lake Case-study
title_sort comparison of local path planning techniques of autonomous surface vehicles for monitoring applications: the ypacarai lake case-study
publisher MDPI AG
series Sensors
issn 1424-8220
publishDate 2020-03-01
description Local path planning is important in the development of autonomous vehicles since it allows a vehicle to adapt their movements to dynamic environments, for instance, when obstacles are detected. This work presents an evaluation of the performance of different local path planning techniques for an Autonomous Surface Vehicle, using a custom-made simulator based on the open-source Robotarium framework. The conducted simulations allow to verify, compare and visualize the solutions of the different techniques. The selected techniques for evaluation include A*, Potential Fields (PF), Rapidly-Exploring Random Trees* (RRT*) and variations of the Fast Marching Method (FMM), along with a proposed new method called Updating the Fast Marching Square method (uFMS). The evaluation proposed in this work includes ways to summarize time and safety measures for local path planning techniques. The results in a Lake environment present the advantages and disadvantages of using each technique. The proposed uFMS and A* have been shown to achieve interesting performance in terms of processing time, distance travelled and security levels. Furthermore, the proposed uFMS algorithm is capable of generating smoother routes.
topic autonomous surface vehicle
local path planning
monitoring applications
motion planning
ypacarai lake
url https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/20/5/1488
work_keys_str_mv AT federicoperalta acomparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT marioarzamendia acomparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT derlisgregor acomparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT danielgreina acomparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT sergiotoral acomparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT federicoperalta comparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT marioarzamendia comparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT derlisgregor comparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT danielgreina comparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
AT sergiotoral comparisonoflocalpathplanningtechniquesofautonomoussurfacevehiclesformonitoringapplicationstheypacarailakecasestudy
_version_ 1724855228519415808