Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors

Febrile illnesses are among the most common reasons for visits to hospitals and clinics worldwide. Since fevers can arise from a wide range of diseases, identifying the causative pathogen is essential not only for effective personal treatment but also for early detection of outbreaks. The Defense Th...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Shawn P. Mulvaney, Lisa A. Fitzgerald, Leila J. Hamdan, Bradley R. Ringeisen, Emily R. Petersen, Jaimee R. Compton, Nina L. McAuliff, Tomasz A. Leski, Chris R. Taitt, David A. Stenger, Christopher A. Myers, Erin Hansen, Michelle Ricketts, Chelsea Hoegberg, Kamonthip Homdayjanakul, Rashid Ansumana, Joseph M. Lamin, Umaru Bangura, Joseph Lahai, Victoria Baio, Direk Limmathurotsakul, Gumphol Wongsuvan, Viriya Hantrakun, Supaporn Wacharapluesadee, Anek Mungaomklang, Opass Putcharoen, Pratoomtong Yatoom, Kriengsak Kruthakool, Robert D. Hontz, Christopher Mores, Crystyan Siles, Amy Morrison, Mark Mayo, Bart J. Currie, Kathryn H. Jacobsen, Kathleen Quinn, Jerold Blutman, Flavia Amariei, John Hannan
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Elsevier 2018-09-01
Series:Sensing and Bio-Sensing Research
Online Access:http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214180418300412
id doaj-605f4a559eb742698527fcf3cbfe043a
record_format Article
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Shawn P. Mulvaney
Lisa A. Fitzgerald
Leila J. Hamdan
Bradley R. Ringeisen
Emily R. Petersen
Jaimee R. Compton
Nina L. McAuliff
Tomasz A. Leski
Chris R. Taitt
David A. Stenger
Christopher A. Myers
Erin Hansen
Michelle Ricketts
Chelsea Hoegberg
Kamonthip Homdayjanakul
Rashid Ansumana
Joseph M. Lamin
Umaru Bangura
Joseph Lahai
Victoria Baio
Direk Limmathurotsakul
Gumphol Wongsuvan
Viriya Hantrakun
Supaporn Wacharapluesadee
Anek Mungaomklang
Opass Putcharoen
Pratoomtong Yatoom
Kriengsak Kruthakool
Robert D. Hontz
Christopher Mores
Crystyan Siles
Amy Morrison
Mark Mayo
Bart J. Currie
Kathryn H. Jacobsen
Kathleen Quinn
Jerold Blutman
Flavia Amariei
John Hannan
spellingShingle Shawn P. Mulvaney
Lisa A. Fitzgerald
Leila J. Hamdan
Bradley R. Ringeisen
Emily R. Petersen
Jaimee R. Compton
Nina L. McAuliff
Tomasz A. Leski
Chris R. Taitt
David A. Stenger
Christopher A. Myers
Erin Hansen
Michelle Ricketts
Chelsea Hoegberg
Kamonthip Homdayjanakul
Rashid Ansumana
Joseph M. Lamin
Umaru Bangura
Joseph Lahai
Victoria Baio
Direk Limmathurotsakul
Gumphol Wongsuvan
Viriya Hantrakun
Supaporn Wacharapluesadee
Anek Mungaomklang
Opass Putcharoen
Pratoomtong Yatoom
Kriengsak Kruthakool
Robert D. Hontz
Christopher Mores
Crystyan Siles
Amy Morrison
Mark Mayo
Bart J. Currie
Kathryn H. Jacobsen
Kathleen Quinn
Jerold Blutman
Flavia Amariei
John Hannan
Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors
Sensing and Bio-Sensing Research
author_facet Shawn P. Mulvaney
Lisa A. Fitzgerald
Leila J. Hamdan
Bradley R. Ringeisen
Emily R. Petersen
Jaimee R. Compton
Nina L. McAuliff
Tomasz A. Leski
Chris R. Taitt
David A. Stenger
Christopher A. Myers
Erin Hansen
Michelle Ricketts
Chelsea Hoegberg
Kamonthip Homdayjanakul
Rashid Ansumana
Joseph M. Lamin
Umaru Bangura
Joseph Lahai
Victoria Baio
Direk Limmathurotsakul
Gumphol Wongsuvan
Viriya Hantrakun
Supaporn Wacharapluesadee
Anek Mungaomklang
Opass Putcharoen
Pratoomtong Yatoom
Kriengsak Kruthakool
Robert D. Hontz
Christopher Mores
Crystyan Siles
Amy Morrison
Mark Mayo
Bart J. Currie
Kathryn H. Jacobsen
Kathleen Quinn
Jerold Blutman
Flavia Amariei
John Hannan
author_sort Shawn P. Mulvaney
title Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors
title_short Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors
title_full Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors
title_fullStr Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors
title_full_unstemmed Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors
title_sort rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in sierra leone, thailand, peru, and australia: successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensors
publisher Elsevier
series Sensing and Bio-Sensing Research
issn 2214-1804
publishDate 2018-09-01
description Febrile illnesses are among the most common reasons for visits to hospitals and clinics worldwide. Since fevers can arise from a wide range of diseases, identifying the causative pathogen is essential not only for effective personal treatment but also for early detection of outbreaks. The Defense Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA) tasked a coalition of commercial, academic, and government researchers with moving diagnostic technology concepts from ideation to field use as rapidly as possible using scientifically sound evaluations. DTRA's 24 Month Challenge program examined >30 technologies before fielding four technologies on four continents. >10,000 in field test results were recorded. Here we discuss our tiered evaluation system to assess candidate technologies developed by commercial partners and the process of field testing those technologies at various front-line clinics in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia. We discuss successes and challenges for introducing two multiplexed lateral flow immunoassay (LFI) tests that detect malaria, dengue fever, melioidosis, and the plague. Additionally we discuss the use of a LFI reader that assisted the interpretation of the assay, communicated results to a data cloud, and greatly facilitated reach-back support. Lastly, we discuss the concurrent field testing of a multiplexed PCR assay on the FilmArray platform, which had an assay pouch specially designed for the 24 Month Challenge. Either standard-of-care or gold-standard testing were run alongside our fielded technologies to benchmark their performance. Keywords: Diagnostic device, Lateral flow immunoassay, Nested PCR, Field testing, Malaria, Dengue fever
url http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214180418300412
work_keys_str_mv AT shawnpmulvaney rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT lisaafitzgerald rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT leilajhamdan rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT bradleyrringeisen rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT emilyrpetersen rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT jaimeercompton rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT ninalmcauliff rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT tomaszaleski rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT chrisrtaitt rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT davidastenger rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT christopheramyers rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT erinhansen rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT michellericketts rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT chelseahoegberg rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT kamonthiphomdayjanakul rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT rashidansumana rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT josephmlamin rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT umarubangura rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT josephlahai rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT victoriabaio rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT direklimmathurotsakul rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT gumpholwongsuvan rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT viriyahantrakun rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT supapornwacharapluesadee rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT anekmungaomklang rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT opassputcharoen rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT pratoomtongyatoom rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT kriengsakkruthakool rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT robertdhontz rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT christophermores rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT crystyansiles rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT amymorrison rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT markmayo rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT bartjcurrie rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT kathrynhjacobsen rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT kathleenquinn rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT jeroldblutman rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT flaviaamariei rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
AT johnhannan rapiddesignandfieldingoffourdiagnostictechnologiesinsierraleonethailandperuandaustraliasuccessesandchallengesfacedintroducingthesebiosensors
_version_ 1716770150651265024
spelling doaj-605f4a559eb742698527fcf3cbfe043a2020-11-24T21:04:42ZengElsevierSensing and Bio-Sensing Research2214-18042018-09-01202233Rapid design and fielding of four diagnostic technologies in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia: Successes and challenges faced introducing these biosensorsShawn P. Mulvaney0Lisa A. Fitzgerald1Leila J. Hamdan2Bradley R. Ringeisen3Emily R. Petersen4Jaimee R. Compton5Nina L. McAuliff6Tomasz A. Leski7Chris R. Taitt8David A. Stenger9Christopher A. Myers10Erin Hansen11Michelle Ricketts12Chelsea Hoegberg13Kamonthip Homdayjanakul14Rashid Ansumana15Joseph M. Lamin16Umaru Bangura17Joseph Lahai18Victoria Baio19Direk Limmathurotsakul20Gumphol Wongsuvan21Viriya Hantrakun22Supaporn Wacharapluesadee23Anek Mungaomklang24Opass Putcharoen25Pratoomtong Yatoom26Kriengsak Kruthakool27Robert D. Hontz28Christopher Mores29Crystyan Siles30Amy Morrison31Mark Mayo32Bart J. Currie33Kathryn H. Jacobsen34Kathleen Quinn35Jerold Blutman36Flavia Amariei37John Hannan38Chemistry Division, US Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC, USA; Corresponding author.Chemistry Division, US Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC, USAChemistry Division, US Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC, USAChemistry Division, US Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC, USANova Research, Inc., Alexandria, VA 22308, USANova Research, Inc., Alexandria, VA 22308, USANova Research, Inc., Alexandria, VA 22308, USACenter for Biomolecular Science and Engineering, US Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC, USACenter for Biomolecular Science and Engineering, US Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC, USACenter for Biomolecular Science and Engineering, US Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC, USAOperational Infectious Diseases Directorate, Naval Health Research Center, San Diego, CA, USAOperational Infectious Diseases Directorate, Naval Health Research Center, San Diego, CA, USA; Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine, Bethesda, MD, USAOperational Infectious Diseases Directorate, Naval Health Research Center, San Diego, CA, USA; Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine, Bethesda, MD, USAOperational Infectious Diseases Directorate, Naval Health Research Center, San Diego, CA, USA; Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine, Bethesda, MD, USAOperational Infectious Diseases Directorate, Naval Health Research Center, San Diego, CA, USA; Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine, Bethesda, MD, USAMercy Hospital Research Laboratory, Bo, Sierra LeoneMercy Hospital Research Laboratory, Bo, Sierra LeoneMercy Hospital Research Laboratory, Bo, Sierra LeoneMercy Hospital Research Laboratory, Bo, Sierra LeoneMercy Hospital Research Laboratory, Bo, Sierra LeoneMahidol-Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, Faculty of Tropical Medicine, Mahidol University, Thailand; Center for Tropical Medicine and Global Health, Nuffield Department of Clinical Medicine, Churchill Hospital, University of Oxford, United Kingdom; Department of Tropical Hygiene, Faculty of Tropical Medicine, Mahidol University, ThailandMahidol-Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, Faculty of Tropical Medicine, Mahidol University, ThailandMahidol-Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, Faculty of Tropical Medicine, Mahidol University, ThailandKing Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, ThailandDebaratana Nakhon Ratchasima Hospital, Nakhon Ratchasima, ThailandDebaratana Nakhon Ratchasima Hospital, Nakhon Ratchasima, ThailandPak Thong Chai Hospital, Nakhon Ratchasima, ThailandChokchai Hospital, Nakhon Ratchasima, ThailandNaval Medical Research Unit 6, Lima, PeruNaval Medical Research Unit 6, Lima, PeruNaval Medical Research Unit 6, Iquitos, PeruNaval Medical Research Unit 6, Iquitos, PeruGlobal and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Darwin, Northern Territory, AustraliaGlobal and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Darwin, Northern Territory, Australia; Department of Infectious Diseases, Royal Darwin Hospital, Darwin, Northern Territory, AustraliaGeorge Mason University, Fairfax, VA, USADefense Threat Reduction Agency, Washington, DC, USADefense Threat Reduction Agency, Washington, DC, USADefense Threat Reduction Agency, Washington, DC, USADefense Threat Reduction Agency, Washington, DC, USAFebrile illnesses are among the most common reasons for visits to hospitals and clinics worldwide. Since fevers can arise from a wide range of diseases, identifying the causative pathogen is essential not only for effective personal treatment but also for early detection of outbreaks. The Defense Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA) tasked a coalition of commercial, academic, and government researchers with moving diagnostic technology concepts from ideation to field use as rapidly as possible using scientifically sound evaluations. DTRA's 24 Month Challenge program examined >30 technologies before fielding four technologies on four continents. >10,000 in field test results were recorded. Here we discuss our tiered evaluation system to assess candidate technologies developed by commercial partners and the process of field testing those technologies at various front-line clinics in Sierra Leone, Thailand, Peru, and Australia. We discuss successes and challenges for introducing two multiplexed lateral flow immunoassay (LFI) tests that detect malaria, dengue fever, melioidosis, and the plague. Additionally we discuss the use of a LFI reader that assisted the interpretation of the assay, communicated results to a data cloud, and greatly facilitated reach-back support. Lastly, we discuss the concurrent field testing of a multiplexed PCR assay on the FilmArray platform, which had an assay pouch specially designed for the 24 Month Challenge. Either standard-of-care or gold-standard testing were run alongside our fielded technologies to benchmark their performance. Keywords: Diagnostic device, Lateral flow immunoassay, Nested PCR, Field testing, Malaria, Dengue feverhttp://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214180418300412