The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound

Introduction. Iodinated contrast media completion angiography (ICM-A) may underestimate the presence of type II endoleak (ELII) after endovascular aortic repair (EVAR), particularly if they are at low flow. Contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) has been proposed as the gold standard in ELII detection...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Chiara Mascoli, Gianluca Faggioli, Enrico Gallitto, Vincenzo Vento, Giuseppe Indelicato, Rodolfo Pini, Andrea Vacirca, Andrea Stella, Mauro Gargiulo
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Hindawi-Wiley 2018-01-01
Series:Contrast Media & Molecular Imaging
Online Access:http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2018/7647165
id doaj-6022b1a56a464904a66330f469dea192
record_format Article
spelling doaj-6022b1a56a464904a66330f469dea1922020-11-25T01:11:50ZengHindawi-WileyContrast Media & Molecular Imaging1555-43091555-43172018-01-01201810.1155/2018/76471657647165The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced UltrasoundChiara Mascoli0Gianluca Faggioli1Enrico Gallitto2Vincenzo Vento3Giuseppe Indelicato4Rodolfo Pini5Andrea Vacirca6Andrea Stella7Mauro Gargiulo8Vascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyVascular Surgery, DIMES, University of Bologna, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, ItalyIntroduction. Iodinated contrast media completion angiography (ICM-A) may underestimate the presence of type II endoleak (ELII) after endovascular aortic repair (EVAR), particularly if they are at low flow. Contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) has been proposed as the gold standard in ELII detection during EVAR follow-up. Intraprocedural carbon dioxide (CO2) angiography has been shown to be useful in this setting; however no comparative studies including these three techniques are currently available. Our aim was to investigate the accuracy of a new automated CO2 angiographic (CO2-A) system in the detection of ELII, by comparing it with ICM-A and CEUS. Methods. A series of consecutive patients undergoing EVAR for abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) were enrolled and submitted to ICM-A and CO2-A during the procedure. The iodinated contrast media were delivered through an automatic injector connected to a pigtail catheter in the suprarenal aorta. CO2 was delivered through a recently available automatic injector connected to a 10 F sheath positioned in the external iliac artery. All patients were blindly evaluated by CEUS within postoperative day 1. The ICM-A and CO2-A ability to detect ELII was compared with that of CEUS through Cohen’s concordance Index (K). Results. Twenty-one patients were enrolled in the study. One (5%), seven (33%), and four (19%) ELII were detected by ICM-A, CO2-A, and CEUS, respectively. The only ELII detected by ICM-A was also detected by CO2-A and CEUS. Three cases of ELII detected by CO2-A were not detected by CEUS. All ELII detected by CEUS were visualized by CO2-A. CEUS and ICM-A showed a poor agreement (Cohen’s K: 0.35) while CEUS and CO2-A showed a substantial agreement (Cohen’s K: 0.65) for ELII detection. Conclusion. CO2-A is safe and effective method for ELII detection in EVAR, with a significantly higher agreement with CEUS if compared with ICM-A. This trial is registered with 155/2015/U/Oss.http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2018/7647165
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Chiara Mascoli
Gianluca Faggioli
Enrico Gallitto
Vincenzo Vento
Giuseppe Indelicato
Rodolfo Pini
Andrea Vacirca
Andrea Stella
Mauro Gargiulo
spellingShingle Chiara Mascoli
Gianluca Faggioli
Enrico Gallitto
Vincenzo Vento
Giuseppe Indelicato
Rodolfo Pini
Andrea Vacirca
Andrea Stella
Mauro Gargiulo
The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound
Contrast Media & Molecular Imaging
author_facet Chiara Mascoli
Gianluca Faggioli
Enrico Gallitto
Vincenzo Vento
Giuseppe Indelicato
Rodolfo Pini
Andrea Vacirca
Andrea Stella
Mauro Gargiulo
author_sort Chiara Mascoli
title The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound
title_short The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound
title_full The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound
title_fullStr The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound
title_full_unstemmed The Assessment of Carbon Dioxide Automated Angiography in Type II Endoleaks Detection: Comparison with Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound
title_sort assessment of carbon dioxide automated angiography in type ii endoleaks detection: comparison with contrast-enhanced ultrasound
publisher Hindawi-Wiley
series Contrast Media & Molecular Imaging
issn 1555-4309
1555-4317
publishDate 2018-01-01
description Introduction. Iodinated contrast media completion angiography (ICM-A) may underestimate the presence of type II endoleak (ELII) after endovascular aortic repair (EVAR), particularly if they are at low flow. Contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) has been proposed as the gold standard in ELII detection during EVAR follow-up. Intraprocedural carbon dioxide (CO2) angiography has been shown to be useful in this setting; however no comparative studies including these three techniques are currently available. Our aim was to investigate the accuracy of a new automated CO2 angiographic (CO2-A) system in the detection of ELII, by comparing it with ICM-A and CEUS. Methods. A series of consecutive patients undergoing EVAR for abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) were enrolled and submitted to ICM-A and CO2-A during the procedure. The iodinated contrast media were delivered through an automatic injector connected to a pigtail catheter in the suprarenal aorta. CO2 was delivered through a recently available automatic injector connected to a 10 F sheath positioned in the external iliac artery. All patients were blindly evaluated by CEUS within postoperative day 1. The ICM-A and CO2-A ability to detect ELII was compared with that of CEUS through Cohen’s concordance Index (K). Results. Twenty-one patients were enrolled in the study. One (5%), seven (33%), and four (19%) ELII were detected by ICM-A, CO2-A, and CEUS, respectively. The only ELII detected by ICM-A was also detected by CO2-A and CEUS. Three cases of ELII detected by CO2-A were not detected by CEUS. All ELII detected by CEUS were visualized by CO2-A. CEUS and ICM-A showed a poor agreement (Cohen’s K: 0.35) while CEUS and CO2-A showed a substantial agreement (Cohen’s K: 0.65) for ELII detection. Conclusion. CO2-A is safe and effective method for ELII detection in EVAR, with a significantly higher agreement with CEUS if compared with ICM-A. This trial is registered with 155/2015/U/Oss.
url http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2018/7647165
work_keys_str_mv AT chiaramascoli theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT gianlucafaggioli theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT enricogallitto theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT vincenzovento theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT giuseppeindelicato theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT rodolfopini theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT andreavacirca theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT andreastella theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT maurogargiulo theassessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT chiaramascoli assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT gianlucafaggioli assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT enricogallitto assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT vincenzovento assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT giuseppeindelicato assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT rodolfopini assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT andreavacirca assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT andreastella assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
AT maurogargiulo assessmentofcarbondioxideautomatedangiographyintypeiiendoleaksdetectioncomparisonwithcontrastenhancedultrasound
_version_ 1725169392244752384