A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group Inference

Graphical models appear well suited for inferring brain connectivity from fMRI data, as they can distinguish between direct and indirect brain connectivity. Nevertheless, biological interpretation requires not only that the multivariate time series are adequately modeled, but also that there is accu...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Aiping Liu, Junning Li, Z. Jane Wang, Martin J. McKeown
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Hindawi Limited 2012-01-01
Series:Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine
Online Access:http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2012/967380
id doaj-5fd5bd8f7ed54df6ac03af9747301251
record_format Article
spelling doaj-5fd5bd8f7ed54df6ac03af97473012512020-11-24T23:45:09ZengHindawi LimitedComputational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine1748-670X1748-67182012-01-01201210.1155/2012/967380967380A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group InferenceAiping Liu0Junning Li1Z. Jane Wang2Martin J. McKeown3Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z4, CanadaLaboratory of Neuro Imaging, Department of Neurology, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USADepartment of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z4, CanadaDepartment of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z4, CanadaGraphical models appear well suited for inferring brain connectivity from fMRI data, as they can distinguish between direct and indirect brain connectivity. Nevertheless, biological interpretation requires not only that the multivariate time series are adequately modeled, but also that there is accurate error-control of the inferred edges. The PCfdr algorithm, which was developed by Li and Wang, was to provide a computationally efficient means to control the false discovery rate (FDR) of computed edges asymptotically. The original PCfdr algorithm was unable to accommodate a priori information about connectivity and was designed to infer connectivity from a single subject rather than a group of subjects. Here we extend the original PCfdr algorithm and propose a multisubject, error-rate-controlled brain connectivity modeling approach that allows incorporation of prior knowledge of connectivity. In simulations, we show that the two proposed extensions can still control the FDR around or below a specified threshold. When the proposed approach is applied to fMRI data in a Parkinson’s disease study, we find robust group evidence of the disease-related changes, the compensatory changes, and the normalizing effect of L-dopa medication. The proposed method provides a robust, accurate, and practical method for the assessment of brain connectivity patterns from functional neuroimaging data.http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2012/967380
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Aiping Liu
Junning Li
Z. Jane Wang
Martin J. McKeown
spellingShingle Aiping Liu
Junning Li
Z. Jane Wang
Martin J. McKeown
A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group Inference
Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine
author_facet Aiping Liu
Junning Li
Z. Jane Wang
Martin J. McKeown
author_sort Aiping Liu
title A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group Inference
title_short A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group Inference
title_full A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group Inference
title_fullStr A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group Inference
title_full_unstemmed A Computationally Efficient, Exploratory Approach to Brain Connectivity Incorporating False Discovery Rate Control, A Priori Knowledge, and Group Inference
title_sort computationally efficient, exploratory approach to brain connectivity incorporating false discovery rate control, a priori knowledge, and group inference
publisher Hindawi Limited
series Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine
issn 1748-670X
1748-6718
publishDate 2012-01-01
description Graphical models appear well suited for inferring brain connectivity from fMRI data, as they can distinguish between direct and indirect brain connectivity. Nevertheless, biological interpretation requires not only that the multivariate time series are adequately modeled, but also that there is accurate error-control of the inferred edges. The PCfdr algorithm, which was developed by Li and Wang, was to provide a computationally efficient means to control the false discovery rate (FDR) of computed edges asymptotically. The original PCfdr algorithm was unable to accommodate a priori information about connectivity and was designed to infer connectivity from a single subject rather than a group of subjects. Here we extend the original PCfdr algorithm and propose a multisubject, error-rate-controlled brain connectivity modeling approach that allows incorporation of prior knowledge of connectivity. In simulations, we show that the two proposed extensions can still control the FDR around or below a specified threshold. When the proposed approach is applied to fMRI data in a Parkinson’s disease study, we find robust group evidence of the disease-related changes, the compensatory changes, and the normalizing effect of L-dopa medication. The proposed method provides a robust, accurate, and practical method for the assessment of brain connectivity patterns from functional neuroimaging data.
url http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2012/967380
work_keys_str_mv AT aipingliu acomputationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
AT junningli acomputationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
AT zjanewang acomputationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
AT martinjmckeown acomputationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
AT aipingliu computationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
AT junningli computationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
AT zjanewang computationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
AT martinjmckeown computationallyefficientexploratoryapproachtobrainconnectivityincorporatingfalsediscoveryratecontrolaprioriknowledgeandgroupinference
_version_ 1725497057820540928