An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga Program

In this paper, we show an unintended effect of the program Ser Pilo Paga (SPP) that was a flagship program of the Colombian government between 2014 and 2018. It was designed as an intervention in the Colombian Higher Education System (CHES) by awarding, in the steady state, individual funding to abo...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Pablo Medina, Natalia Ariza, Pablo Navas, Fernando Rojas, Gina Parody, Juan Alejandro Valdivia, Roberto Zarama, Juan Felipe Penagos
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Hindawi-Wiley 2018-01-01
Series:Complexity
Online Access:http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2018/3528206
id doaj-596c2656077e4df1b02178ae6cd00b4e
record_format Article
spelling doaj-596c2656077e4df1b02178ae6cd00b4e2020-11-25T01:13:59ZengHindawi-WileyComplexity1076-27871099-05262018-01-01201810.1155/2018/35282063528206An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga ProgramPablo Medina0Natalia Ariza1Pablo Navas2Fernando Rojas3Gina Parody4Juan Alejandro Valdivia5Roberto Zarama6Juan Felipe Penagos7Departamento de Física, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Chile, Santiago, ChileCeiBA Complexity Research Center, Bogotá, ColombiaCeiBA Complexity Research Center, Bogotá, ColombiaCeiBA Complexity Research Center, Bogotá, ColombiaCeiBA Complexity Research Center, Bogotá, ColombiaDepartamento de Física, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Chile, Santiago, ChileCeiBA Complexity Research Center, Bogotá, ColombiaCeiBA Complexity Research Center, Bogotá, ColombiaIn this paper, we show an unintended effect of the program Ser Pilo Paga (SPP) that was a flagship program of the Colombian government between 2014 and 2018. It was designed as an intervention in the Colombian Higher Education System (CHES) by awarding, in the steady state, individual funding to about 40,000 students. Every year, 10,000 new students were chosen from the best applicants in the top decile of the population in the entrance exam to higher education in Colombia that also came from families that live under the level of poverty according to a national survey. Our approach, based on an intensive study of the changes in the statistical distributions of the exam scores during these four years, provides evidence of student performance improvements not only of the beneficiaries of the program, but also of the whole student population. This shows that the program opened similar opportunities for all the students, especially for the poorest ones. The program drove a reduction in the gap between students of the upper strata of the population and those of the lowest strata that usually did not access a high quality institution of higher education due to the lack of funding. This result has opened a debate about the optimal way of funding higher education.http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2018/3528206
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Pablo Medina
Natalia Ariza
Pablo Navas
Fernando Rojas
Gina Parody
Juan Alejandro Valdivia
Roberto Zarama
Juan Felipe Penagos
spellingShingle Pablo Medina
Natalia Ariza
Pablo Navas
Fernando Rojas
Gina Parody
Juan Alejandro Valdivia
Roberto Zarama
Juan Felipe Penagos
An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga Program
Complexity
author_facet Pablo Medina
Natalia Ariza
Pablo Navas
Fernando Rojas
Gina Parody
Juan Alejandro Valdivia
Roberto Zarama
Juan Felipe Penagos
author_sort Pablo Medina
title An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga Program
title_short An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga Program
title_full An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga Program
title_fullStr An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga Program
title_full_unstemmed An Unintended Effect of Financing the University Education of the Most Brilliant and Poorest Colombian Students: The Case of the Intervention of the Ser Pilo Paga Program
title_sort unintended effect of financing the university education of the most brilliant and poorest colombian students: the case of the intervention of the ser pilo paga program
publisher Hindawi-Wiley
series Complexity
issn 1076-2787
1099-0526
publishDate 2018-01-01
description In this paper, we show an unintended effect of the program Ser Pilo Paga (SPP) that was a flagship program of the Colombian government between 2014 and 2018. It was designed as an intervention in the Colombian Higher Education System (CHES) by awarding, in the steady state, individual funding to about 40,000 students. Every year, 10,000 new students were chosen from the best applicants in the top decile of the population in the entrance exam to higher education in Colombia that also came from families that live under the level of poverty according to a national survey. Our approach, based on an intensive study of the changes in the statistical distributions of the exam scores during these four years, provides evidence of student performance improvements not only of the beneficiaries of the program, but also of the whole student population. This shows that the program opened similar opportunities for all the students, especially for the poorest ones. The program drove a reduction in the gap between students of the upper strata of the population and those of the lowest strata that usually did not access a high quality institution of higher education due to the lack of funding. This result has opened a debate about the optimal way of funding higher education.
url http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2018/3528206
work_keys_str_mv AT pablomedina anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT nataliaariza anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT pablonavas anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT fernandorojas anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT ginaparody anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT juanalejandrovaldivia anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT robertozarama anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT juanfelipepenagos anunintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT pablomedina unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT nataliaariza unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT pablonavas unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT fernandorojas unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT ginaparody unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT juanalejandrovaldivia unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT robertozarama unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
AT juanfelipepenagos unintendedeffectoffinancingtheuniversityeducationofthemostbrilliantandpoorestcolombianstudentsthecaseoftheinterventionoftheserpilopagaprogram
_version_ 1725159409093443584