Engaging Non-State Security Providers: Whither the Rule of Law?

• Main Author: Timothy Donais
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Centre for Security Governance 2017-07-01
• Series: Stability : International Journal of Security and Development
• Online Access: http://www.stabilityjournal.org/articles/553

The primacy of the rule of law has long been seen as one of the essential principles of security sector reform (SSR) programming, and part of the larger gospel of SSR is that the accountability of security providers is best guaranteed by embedding security governance within a rule of law framework. Acknowledging the reality of non-state security provision, however, presents a challenge to thinking about SSR as merely the extension of the rule of law into the security realm, in large part because whatever legitimacy non-state security providers possess tends to be grounded in 'extralegal' foundations. This paper – more conceptual than empirical in its approach – considers the implications of hybrid forms of security governance for thinking about the relationship between SSR and rule of law promotion, and argues that the rule of law still provides a useful source of strategic direction for SSR programming.