The Consequences of the National Math and Science Performance Environment for Gender Differences in STEM Aspiration

• Main Authors: Allison Mann, Thomas A. DiPrete
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Society for Sociological Science 2016-07-01
• Series: Sociological Science
• Subjects: Careers in Science and Technology; Cross-cultural Research; Education; Gender Inequalities
• Online Access: https://www.sociologicalscience.com/articles-v3-25-568/
• ISSN: 2330-6696; 2330-6696

Using the lens of expectation states theory, which we formalize in Bayesian terms, this article examines the influences of national performance and self-assessment contexts on gender differences in the rate of aspiring to science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) occupations. We demonstrate that girls hold themselves to a higher performance standard than do boys before forming STEM orientations, and this gender "standards gap" grows with the strength of a country’s performance environment. We also demonstrate that a repeatedly observed paradox in this literature—namely, that the STEM gender gap increases with a more strongly gender-egalitarian national culture—vanishes when the national performance culture is taken into account. Whereas other research has proposed theories to explain the apparent paradox as an empirical reality, we demonstrate that the empirical relationship is as expected; net of the performance environment, countries with a more gender-egalitarian culture have a smaller gender gap in STEM orientations. We also find, consistent with our theory, that the proportion of high-performing girls among STEM aspirants grows with the strength of the national performance environment even as the overall gender gap in STEM orientations grows because of offsetting behavior by students at the lower end of the performance distribution.