Investigation of Error Distribution in the Back-Calculation of Breakage Function Model Parameters via Nonlinear Programming

• Main Authors: Jihoe Kwon, Heechan Cho
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: MDPI AG 2021-04-01
• Series: Minerals
• Subjects: breakage parameters; back-calculation; error distribution; wide-range searching; population balance model; conjugate gradient method
• Online Access: https://www.mdpi.com/2075-163X/11/4/425

Despite its effectiveness in determining breakage function parameters (BFPs) for quantifying breakage characteristics in mineral grinding processes, the back-calculation method has limitations owing to the uncertainty regarding the distribution of the error function. In this work, using Korean uranium and molybdenum ores, we show that the limitation can be overcome by searching over a wide range of initial values based on the conjugate gradient method. We also visualized the distribution of the sum of squares of the error in the two-dimensional parameter space. The results showed that the error function was strictly convex, and the main problem in the back-calculation of the breakage functions was the flat surface of the objective function rather than the occurrence of local minima. Based on our results, we inferred that the flat surface problem could be significantly mitigated by searching over a wide range of initial values. Back-calculation using a wide range of initial values yields BFPs similar to those obtained from single-sized-feed breakage tests (SSFBTs) up to four-dimensional parameter spaces. Therefore, by searching over a wide range of initial values, the feasibility of the back-calculation approach can be significantly improved with a minimum number of SSFBTs.