An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011

Antibody testing is the most common way to diagnose HIV infection in laboratories which need good quality. The objective of this retrospective study is to assess the HIV diagnosis performances of 216 government and private laboratories from 17 provinces in the Northern Thailand participated in Profi...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Boonrat Vongchompoo
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Chaing Mai University 2012-09-01
Series:Journal of Associated Medical Sciences
Subjects:
HIV
Online Access:https://www.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/bulletinAMS/article/view/60037
id doaj-4ce3c4e18e354123bb7a5cdaeca14873
record_format Article
spelling doaj-4ce3c4e18e354123bb7a5cdaeca148732020-11-24T21:34:38ZengChaing Mai UniversityJournal of Associated Medical Sciences2539-60562539-60562012-09-01453171760037An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011Boonrat Vongchompoo0Regional Medical Sciences Center 10, Department of Medical Sciences, Ministry of Public HealthAntibody testing is the most common way to diagnose HIV infection in laboratories which need good quality. The objective of this retrospective study is to assess the HIV diagnosis performances of 216 government and private laboratories from 17 provinces in the Northern Thailand participated in Proficiency Testing for HIV Serology in Northern Scheme during 2009–2011 that tested nine trial samples. Testing algorithms, serology assays, the accuracy and precision rates were compared among nine trials. The results showed that the trend of HIV testing algorithm by three methods was significantly increased (p<0.001) while one method was significantly reduced (p<0.0001). The serological method performed were classified into four assay including machine-based assay (MBA), microplate Enzyme immunoassay (EIA), rapid assay and Particle agglutination (PA). Rapid assay was the most popular assay (57.19 %) followed by PA, MBA and EIA (31.30 %, 10.63 % and 0.88 % respectively). The using rate of EIA was significantly reduced (p<0.0001) but rapid test, PA and MBA were not significantly changed throughout the period time. However, the trend of using MBA was slightly increased. The accuracy and precision rates of all assays were significantly different. (p=0.02) EIA had the best accuracy rate at 100 %, followed by rapid test, MBA and PA at 99.86 %, 99.83 % and 97.79% respectively. In addition, EIA had the best precision rate at 100%, followed by rapid test, MBA and PA at 99.85 %, 99.42% and 98.07% respectively. The average of accuracy and precision rates of result interpretation were 99.66% and 99.45% respectively that were not significantly throughout the period time. (p=0.08 and p=0.10 respectively) The result showed that laboratories in the Northern Thailand have had the good performance and high quality for HIV testing.https://www.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/bulletinAMS/article/view/60037laboratory proficiency testingHIVparticle agglutinationmachine-based assay
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Boonrat Vongchompoo
spellingShingle Boonrat Vongchompoo
An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011
Journal of Associated Medical Sciences
laboratory proficiency testing
HIV
particle agglutination
machine-based assay
author_facet Boonrat Vongchompoo
author_sort Boonrat Vongchompoo
title An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011
title_short An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011
title_full An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011
title_fullStr An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011
title_full_unstemmed An assessment of laboratories performance for anti HIV testing in the Northern Thailand, during 2009–2011
title_sort assessment of laboratories performance for anti hiv testing in the northern thailand, during 2009–2011
publisher Chaing Mai University
series Journal of Associated Medical Sciences
issn 2539-6056
2539-6056
publishDate 2012-09-01
description Antibody testing is the most common way to diagnose HIV infection in laboratories which need good quality. The objective of this retrospective study is to assess the HIV diagnosis performances of 216 government and private laboratories from 17 provinces in the Northern Thailand participated in Proficiency Testing for HIV Serology in Northern Scheme during 2009–2011 that tested nine trial samples. Testing algorithms, serology assays, the accuracy and precision rates were compared among nine trials. The results showed that the trend of HIV testing algorithm by three methods was significantly increased (p<0.001) while one method was significantly reduced (p<0.0001). The serological method performed were classified into four assay including machine-based assay (MBA), microplate Enzyme immunoassay (EIA), rapid assay and Particle agglutination (PA). Rapid assay was the most popular assay (57.19 %) followed by PA, MBA and EIA (31.30 %, 10.63 % and 0.88 % respectively). The using rate of EIA was significantly reduced (p<0.0001) but rapid test, PA and MBA were not significantly changed throughout the period time. However, the trend of using MBA was slightly increased. The accuracy and precision rates of all assays were significantly different. (p=0.02) EIA had the best accuracy rate at 100 %, followed by rapid test, MBA and PA at 99.86 %, 99.83 % and 97.79% respectively. In addition, EIA had the best precision rate at 100%, followed by rapid test, MBA and PA at 99.85 %, 99.42% and 98.07% respectively. The average of accuracy and precision rates of result interpretation were 99.66% and 99.45% respectively that were not significantly throughout the period time. (p=0.08 and p=0.10 respectively) The result showed that laboratories in the Northern Thailand have had the good performance and high quality for HIV testing.
topic laboratory proficiency testing
HIV
particle agglutination
machine-based assay
url https://www.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/bulletinAMS/article/view/60037
work_keys_str_mv AT boonratvongchompoo anassessmentoflaboratoriesperformanceforantihivtestinginthenorthernthailandduring20092011
AT boonratvongchompoo assessmentoflaboratoriesperformanceforantihivtestinginthenorthernthailandduring20092011
_version_ 1725948519871676416