Methods and procedures of transdisciplinary knowledge integration: empirical insights from four thematic synthesis processes

• Main Authors: Sabine Hoffmann, Christian Pohl, Janet G. Hering
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Resilience Alliance 2017-03-01
• Series: Ecology and Society
• Subjects: knowledge integration; methods; procedures; sustainable water management; synthesis
• Online Access: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol22/iss1/art27/

What methods and procedures support transdisciplinary knowledge integration? We address this question by exploring knowledge integration within four thematic synthesis processes of the Swiss National Research Programme 61 Sustainable Water Management (NRP 61). Drawing on literature from inter- and transdisciplinary research, we developed an analytical framework to map different methods and procedures of knowledge integration. We use this framework to characterize the variety of methods and procedures that were combined in the four processes to produce thematic synthesis reports. We suggest that the variety of combinations observed reflects the different objectives and questions that guided the processes of knowledge integration as well as the different roles that leaders assumed in these processes. Although the framework was developed in the course of NRP 61, we consider it as a basis for designing ex ante new synthesis processes by defining and sequencing different synthesis stages and by identifying, for each stage, the contributions of specific scientific and societal actors, the purpose of their contributions, and the methods and procedures supporting their contributions. Used in a formative evaluation process, the framework supports reflection on and adaptation of synthesis processes and also facilitates the generation of new knowledge for designing future processes.