Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”

Chronic recalcitrant dermatophytoses, due to <i>Trichophyton</i> (<i>T</i>.) <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII are on the rise in India and are noteworthy for their predominance. It would not be wrong to assume that travel and migration would be responsible for the...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Pietro Nenoff, Shyam B. Verma, Andreas Ebert, Anke Süß, Eleni Fischer, Elke Auerswald, Stephanie Dessoi, Wencke Hofmann, Simone Schmidt, Kathrin Neubert, Regina Renner, Sirius Sohl, Uta Hradetzky, Ursula Krusche, Hans-Christian Wenzel, Annegret Staginnus, Jörg Schaller, Valentina Müller, Christiane Tauer, Matthias Gebhardt, Katja Schubert, Zaid Almustafa, Rudolf Stadler, Andrea Fuchs, Cassian Sitaru, Carsten Retzlaff, Cora Overbeck, Thomas Neumann, Anette Kerschnitzki, Stephan Krause, Martin Schaller, Birgit Walker, Thomas Walther, Lars Köhler, Manuela Albrecht, Ursula Willing, Michel Monod, Karine Salamin, Anke Burmester, Daniela Koch, Constanze Krüger, Silke Uhrlaß
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-10-01
Series:Journal of Fungi
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/6/4/207
id doaj-3f2559c8dc4345d1bbbea4cca7d037d8
record_format Article
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Pietro Nenoff
Shyam B. Verma
Andreas Ebert
Anke Süß
Eleni Fischer
Elke Auerswald
Stephanie Dessoi
Wencke Hofmann
Simone Schmidt
Kathrin Neubert
Regina Renner
Sirius Sohl
Uta Hradetzky
Ursula Krusche
Hans-Christian Wenzel
Annegret Staginnus
Jörg Schaller
Valentina Müller
Christiane Tauer
Matthias Gebhardt
Katja Schubert
Zaid Almustafa
Rudolf Stadler
Andrea Fuchs
Cassian Sitaru
Carsten Retzlaff
Cora Overbeck
Thomas Neumann
Anette Kerschnitzki
Stephan Krause
Martin Schaller
Birgit Walker
Thomas Walther
Lars Köhler
Manuela Albrecht
Ursula Willing
Michel Monod
Karine Salamin
Anke Burmester
Daniela Koch
Constanze Krüger
Silke Uhrlaß
spellingShingle Pietro Nenoff
Shyam B. Verma
Andreas Ebert
Anke Süß
Eleni Fischer
Elke Auerswald
Stephanie Dessoi
Wencke Hofmann
Simone Schmidt
Kathrin Neubert
Regina Renner
Sirius Sohl
Uta Hradetzky
Ursula Krusche
Hans-Christian Wenzel
Annegret Staginnus
Jörg Schaller
Valentina Müller
Christiane Tauer
Matthias Gebhardt
Katja Schubert
Zaid Almustafa
Rudolf Stadler
Andrea Fuchs
Cassian Sitaru
Carsten Retzlaff
Cora Overbeck
Thomas Neumann
Anette Kerschnitzki
Stephan Krause
Martin Schaller
Birgit Walker
Thomas Walther
Lars Köhler
Manuela Albrecht
Ursula Willing
Michel Monod
Karine Salamin
Anke Burmester
Daniela Koch
Constanze Krüger
Silke Uhrlaß
Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”
Journal of Fungi
dermatophytoses
terbinafine-resistant
squalene epoxidase
point mutation
transmission
Itraconazole
author_facet Pietro Nenoff
Shyam B. Verma
Andreas Ebert
Anke Süß
Eleni Fischer
Elke Auerswald
Stephanie Dessoi
Wencke Hofmann
Simone Schmidt
Kathrin Neubert
Regina Renner
Sirius Sohl
Uta Hradetzky
Ursula Krusche
Hans-Christian Wenzel
Annegret Staginnus
Jörg Schaller
Valentina Müller
Christiane Tauer
Matthias Gebhardt
Katja Schubert
Zaid Almustafa
Rudolf Stadler
Andrea Fuchs
Cassian Sitaru
Carsten Retzlaff
Cora Overbeck
Thomas Neumann
Anette Kerschnitzki
Stephan Krause
Martin Schaller
Birgit Walker
Thomas Walther
Lars Köhler
Manuela Albrecht
Ursula Willing
Michel Monod
Karine Salamin
Anke Burmester
Daniela Koch
Constanze Krüger
Silke Uhrlaß
author_sort Pietro Nenoff
title Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”
title_short Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”
title_full Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”
title_fullStr Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”
title_full_unstemmed Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”
title_sort spread of terbinafine-resistant <i>trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> type viii (india) in germany–“the tip of the iceberg?”
publisher MDPI AG
series Journal of Fungi
issn 2309-608X
publishDate 2020-10-01
description Chronic recalcitrant dermatophytoses, due to <i>Trichophyton</i> (<i>T</i>.) <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII are on the rise in India and are noteworthy for their predominance. It would not be wrong to assume that travel and migration would be responsible for the spread of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII from India, with many strains resistant to terbinafine, to other parts of the world. From September 2016 until March 2020, a total of 29 strains of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) were isolated. All patients were residents of Germany: 12 females, 15 males and the gender of the remaining two was not assignable. Patients originated from India (11), Pakistan (two), Bangladesh (one), Iraq (two), Bahrain (one), Libya (one) and other unspecified countries (10). At least two patients were German-born residents. Most samples (21) were collected in 2019 and 2020. All 29 <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> isolates were sequenced (internal transcribed spacer (ITS) and translation elongation factor 1-α gene (TEF1-α)). All were identified as genotype VIII (India) of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i>. In vitro resistance testing revealed 13/29 strains (45%) to be terbinafine-resistant with minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) breakpoints ≥0.2 µg/mL. The remaining 16 strains (55%) were terbinafine-sensitive. Point mutation analysis revealed that 10/13 resistant strains exhibited Phe<sup>397</sup>Leu amino acid substitution of squalene epoxidase (SQLE), indicative for in vitro resistance to terbinafine. Two resistant strains showed combined Phe<sup>397</sup>Leu and Ala<sup>448</sup>Thr amino acid substitutions, and one strain a single Leu<sup>393</sup>Phe amino acid substitution. Out of 16 terbinafine-sensitive strains, in eight Ala<sup>448</sup>Thr, and in one Ala<sup>448</sup>Thr +, new Val<sup>444</sup> Ile amino acid substitutions were detected. Resistance to both itraconazole and voriconazole was observed in three out of 13 analyzed strains. Treatment included topical ciclopirox olamine plus topical miconazole or sertaconazole. Oral itraconazole 200 mg twice daily for four to eight weeks was found to be adequate. Terbinafine-resistant <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII are being increasingly isolated. In Germany, transmission of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII from the Indian subcontinent to Europe should be viewed as a significant public health issue.
topic dermatophytoses
terbinafine-resistant
squalene epoxidase
point mutation
transmission
Itraconazole
url https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/6/4/207
work_keys_str_mv AT pietronenoff spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT shyambverma spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT andreasebert spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT ankesuß spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT elenifischer spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT elkeauerswald spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT stephaniedessoi spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT wenckehofmann spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT simoneschmidt spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT kathrinneubert spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT reginarenner spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT siriussohl spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT utahradetzky spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT ursulakrusche spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT hanschristianwenzel spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT annegretstaginnus spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT jorgschaller spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT valentinamuller spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT christianetauer spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT matthiasgebhardt spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT katjaschubert spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT zaidalmustafa spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT rudolfstadler spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT andreafuchs spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT cassiansitaru spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT carstenretzlaff spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT coraoverbeck spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT thomasneumann spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT anettekerschnitzki spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT stephankrause spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT martinschaller spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT birgitwalker spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT thomaswalther spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT larskohler spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT manuelaalbrecht spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT ursulawilling spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT michelmonod spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT karinesalamin spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT ankeburmester spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT danielakoch spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT constanzekruger spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
AT silkeuhrlaß spreadofterbinafineresistantitrichophytonmentagrophytesitypeviiiindiaingermanythetipoftheiceberg
_version_ 1724531592857124864
spelling doaj-3f2559c8dc4345d1bbbea4cca7d037d82020-11-25T03:41:07ZengMDPI AGJournal of Fungi2309-608X2020-10-01620720710.3390/jof6040207Spread of Terbinafine-Resistant <i>Trichophyton mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) in Germany–“The Tip of the Iceberg?”Pietro Nenoff0Shyam B. Verma1Andreas Ebert2Anke Süß3Eleni Fischer4Elke Auerswald5Stephanie Dessoi6Wencke Hofmann7Simone Schmidt8Kathrin Neubert9Regina Renner10Sirius Sohl11Uta Hradetzky12Ursula Krusche13Hans-Christian Wenzel14Annegret Staginnus15Jörg Schaller16Valentina Müller17Christiane Tauer18Matthias Gebhardt19Katja Schubert20Zaid Almustafa21Rudolf Stadler22Andrea Fuchs23Cassian Sitaru24Carsten Retzlaff25Cora Overbeck26Thomas Neumann27Anette Kerschnitzki28Stephan Krause29Martin Schaller30Birgit Walker31Thomas Walther32Lars Köhler33Manuela Albrecht34Ursula Willing35Michel Monod36Karine Salamin37Anke Burmester38Daniela Koch39Constanze Krüger40Silke Uhrlaß41Labor für Medizinische Mikrobiologie, 04571 Rötha OT Mölbis, Germany“Nirvan” and “In Skin” Clinics, Vadodara, 390020 Gujarat, IndiaLabor für Medizinische Mikrobiologie, 04571 Rötha OT Mölbis, GermanyHautärztin, Gemeinschaftspraxis Allgemeinmedizin und Dermatologie, Kurfürstenstraße 23 a, 54616 Wittlich, GermanyHautarztpraxis Gunhild Kratzsch, Kochstraße 66, 04275 Leipzig, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Lungwitzer Straße 30, 09337 Hohenstein-Ernstthal, GermanyHautzentrum Nordwest, Tituscorso 2-6, 60439 Frankfurt am Main, GermanyHautzentrum Nordwest, Tituscorso 2-6, 60439 Frankfurt am Main, GermanyHautarztpraxis im MVZ Friedrichstadt, Friedrichstraße 41, Haus A-Haupteingang-1. OG, 01067 Dresden, GermanyHautarztpraxis Dipl. med. Kathrin Neubert, Bertolt- Brecht-Straße 2, 09217 Burgstädt, GermanyGemeinschaftspraxis Dres. med. S. Sohl & R. Renner, Katharinenstr. 33, 73728 Esslingen, GermanyGemeinschaftspraxis Dres. med. S. Sohl & R. Renner, Katharinenstr. 33, 73728 Esslingen, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Landsberger Straße 4, 04157 Leipzig, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Landsberger Straße 4, 04157 Leipzig, GermanyHautarztpraxis/Phlebologie, Waldkerbelstraße 12, 04329 Leipzig, GermanyHautarztpraxis, 04668 Grimma, GermanyDermatopathologie Duisburg, J. Schaller und C. Hendricks, 47166 Duisburg, GermanyHelios Klinikum Duisburg, Klinik für Dermatologie, Allergologie und Phlebologie, 47166 Duisburg, GermanyHautarztpraxis Christiane Tauer, Marcel- Callo- Platz 4, 98544 Zella-Mehlis, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Matthias Gebhardt, Leipziger Str. 90, 08058 Zwickau, GermanyHautarztpraxis Dresden, Loschwitzer Straße 40, D-01309 Dresden, GermanyKlinik für Dermatologie, Charite, 10117 Berlin, GermanyUniversitätsklinik für Dermatologie, Venerologie, Allergologie und Phlebologie, Johannes Wesling Klinikum Minden, Hans-Nolte-Straße 1, D-32429 Minden, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Darwinstr. 1, 04600 Altenburg, GermanyUniversitätsklinikum Freiburg, Klinik für Dermatologie und Venereologie, Mykologisches Labor, Hauptstraße 7, 79104 Freiburg, GermanyLabor Dres. Löbel und Retzlaff, Felsbachstr. 5, 07745 Jena, GermanyGemeinschaftspraxis Dermatologie Cora Overbeck und Thomas Neumann, Lange Str. 53, 34346 Hann. Münden, GermanyGemeinschaftspraxis Dermatologie Cora Overbeck und Thomas Neumann, Lange Str. 53, 34346 Hann. Münden, GermanyKlinik für Dermatologie, Klinikum Uni München, Mykologisches Labor, Frauenlobstr. 9-11, 80337 München, GermanyStephan Krause, Bundeswehrkrankenhaus Berlin, Klinik III Dermatologie, Scharnhorststraße 13, 10115 Berlin, GermanyDepartment of Dermatology, University Clinic Tübingen, Liebermeisterstraße 25, 72076 Tübingen, GermanyDepartment of Dermatology, University Clinic Tübingen, Liebermeisterstraße 25, 72076 Tübingen, GermanyThomas Walther, Hautarztpraxis, Bästleinstr. 6, 04347 Leipzig, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Boppstr. 20-24, 55118 Mainz, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Mockauer Str. 123-125, 04357 Leipzig, GermanyHautarztpraxis, Mockauer Str. 123-125, 04357 Leipzig, GermanyDermatology Service, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, 1011 Lausanne, SwitzerlandDermatology Service, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, 1011 Lausanne, SwitzerlandDepartment of Dermatology, University Hospital Jena, Erfurter Str. 35, D-07743 Jena, GermanyLabor für Medizinische Mikrobiologie, 04571 Rötha OT Mölbis, GermanyLabor für Medizinische Mikrobiologie, 04571 Rötha OT Mölbis, GermanyLabor für Medizinische Mikrobiologie, 04571 Rötha OT Mölbis, GermanyChronic recalcitrant dermatophytoses, due to <i>Trichophyton</i> (<i>T</i>.) <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII are on the rise in India and are noteworthy for their predominance. It would not be wrong to assume that travel and migration would be responsible for the spread of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII from India, with many strains resistant to terbinafine, to other parts of the world. From September 2016 until March 2020, a total of 29 strains of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII (India) were isolated. All patients were residents of Germany: 12 females, 15 males and the gender of the remaining two was not assignable. Patients originated from India (11), Pakistan (two), Bangladesh (one), Iraq (two), Bahrain (one), Libya (one) and other unspecified countries (10). At least two patients were German-born residents. Most samples (21) were collected in 2019 and 2020. All 29 <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> isolates were sequenced (internal transcribed spacer (ITS) and translation elongation factor 1-α gene (TEF1-α)). All were identified as genotype VIII (India) of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i>. In vitro resistance testing revealed 13/29 strains (45%) to be terbinafine-resistant with minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) breakpoints ≥0.2 µg/mL. The remaining 16 strains (55%) were terbinafine-sensitive. Point mutation analysis revealed that 10/13 resistant strains exhibited Phe<sup>397</sup>Leu amino acid substitution of squalene epoxidase (SQLE), indicative for in vitro resistance to terbinafine. Two resistant strains showed combined Phe<sup>397</sup>Leu and Ala<sup>448</sup>Thr amino acid substitutions, and one strain a single Leu<sup>393</sup>Phe amino acid substitution. Out of 16 terbinafine-sensitive strains, in eight Ala<sup>448</sup>Thr, and in one Ala<sup>448</sup>Thr +, new Val<sup>444</sup> Ile amino acid substitutions were detected. Resistance to both itraconazole and voriconazole was observed in three out of 13 analyzed strains. Treatment included topical ciclopirox olamine plus topical miconazole or sertaconazole. Oral itraconazole 200 mg twice daily for four to eight weeks was found to be adequate. Terbinafine-resistant <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII are being increasingly isolated. In Germany, transmission of <i>T</i>. <i>mentagrophytes</i> Type VIII from the Indian subcontinent to Europe should be viewed as a significant public health issue.https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/6/4/207dermatophytosesterbinafine-resistantsqualene epoxidasepoint mutationtransmissionItraconazole