Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and Zoonoses

To prioritize 100 animal diseases and zoonoses in Europe, we used a multicriteria decision-making procedure based on opinions of experts and evidence-based data. Forty international experts performed intracategory and intercategory weighting of 57 prioritization criteria. Two methods (deterministic...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Marie-France Humblet, Sébastien Vandeputte, Adelin Albert, Christiane Gosset, Nathalie Kirschvink, Eric Haubruge, Fabienne Fecher-Bourgeois, Paul-Pierre Pastoret, Claude Saegerman
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2012-04-01
Series:Emerging Infectious Diseases
Subjects:
Online Access:https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/18/4/11-1151_article
id doaj-3d9893805ada4ac28911328e50ba918e
record_format Article
spelling doaj-3d9893805ada4ac28911328e50ba918e2020-11-25T00:33:25ZengCenters for Disease Control and PreventionEmerging Infectious Diseases1080-60401080-60592012-04-0118410.3201/eid1804.111151Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and ZoonosesMarie-France HumbletSébastien VandeputteAdelin AlbertChristiane GossetNathalie KirschvinkEric HaubrugeFabienne Fecher-BourgeoisPaul-Pierre PastoretClaude SaegermanTo prioritize 100 animal diseases and zoonoses in Europe, we used a multicriteria decision-making procedure based on opinions of experts and evidence-based data. Forty international experts performed intracategory and intercategory weighting of 57 prioritization criteria. Two methods (deterministic with mean of each weight and probabilistic with distribution functions of weights by using Monte Carlo simulation) were used to calculate a score for each disease. Consecutive ranking was established. Few differences were observed between each method. Compared with previous prioritization methods, our procedure is evidence based, includes a range of fields and criteria while considering uncertainty, and will be useful for analyzing diseases that affect public health.https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/18/4/11-1151_articleanimal diseaseszoonosesprioritizationmultianalysis criteriamultidisciplinary methodevidence-based method
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Marie-France Humblet
Sébastien Vandeputte
Adelin Albert
Christiane Gosset
Nathalie Kirschvink
Eric Haubruge
Fabienne Fecher-Bourgeois
Paul-Pierre Pastoret
Claude Saegerman
spellingShingle Marie-France Humblet
Sébastien Vandeputte
Adelin Albert
Christiane Gosset
Nathalie Kirschvink
Eric Haubruge
Fabienne Fecher-Bourgeois
Paul-Pierre Pastoret
Claude Saegerman
Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and Zoonoses
Emerging Infectious Diseases
animal diseases
zoonoses
prioritization
multianalysis criteria
multidisciplinary method
evidence-based method
author_facet Marie-France Humblet
Sébastien Vandeputte
Adelin Albert
Christiane Gosset
Nathalie Kirschvink
Eric Haubruge
Fabienne Fecher-Bourgeois
Paul-Pierre Pastoret
Claude Saegerman
author_sort Marie-France Humblet
title Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and Zoonoses
title_short Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and Zoonoses
title_full Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and Zoonoses
title_fullStr Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and Zoonoses
title_full_unstemmed Multidisciplinary and Evidence-based Method for Prioritizing Diseases of Food-producing Animals and Zoonoses
title_sort multidisciplinary and evidence-based method for prioritizing diseases of food-producing animals and zoonoses
publisher Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
series Emerging Infectious Diseases
issn 1080-6040
1080-6059
publishDate 2012-04-01
description To prioritize 100 animal diseases and zoonoses in Europe, we used a multicriteria decision-making procedure based on opinions of experts and evidence-based data. Forty international experts performed intracategory and intercategory weighting of 57 prioritization criteria. Two methods (deterministic with mean of each weight and probabilistic with distribution functions of weights by using Monte Carlo simulation) were used to calculate a score for each disease. Consecutive ranking was established. Few differences were observed between each method. Compared with previous prioritization methods, our procedure is evidence based, includes a range of fields and criteria while considering uncertainty, and will be useful for analyzing diseases that affect public health.
topic animal diseases
zoonoses
prioritization
multianalysis criteria
multidisciplinary method
evidence-based method
url https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/18/4/11-1151_article
work_keys_str_mv AT mariefrancehumblet multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT sebastienvandeputte multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT adelinalbert multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT christianegosset multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT nathaliekirschvink multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT erichaubruge multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT fabiennefecherbourgeois multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT paulpierrepastoret multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
AT claudesaegerman multidisciplinaryandevidencebasedmethodforprioritizingdiseasesoffoodproducinganimalsandzoonoses
_version_ 1725316997761204224