Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls

Abstract Passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) offers opportunities to collect data on the occurrence of vocal species for long periods of time, at multiple locations, and under a range of environmental conditions. Some species emit individually distinctive calls, including bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: H. Bailey, A. D. Fandel, K. Silva, E. Gryzb, E. McDonald, A. L. Hoover, M. B. Ogburn, A. N. Rice
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Wiley 2021-08-01
Series:Ecosphere
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1002/ecs2.3685
id doaj-37c47e1c1c8b4026bd52930830ba6849
record_format Article
spelling doaj-37c47e1c1c8b4026bd52930830ba68492021-08-27T02:22:40ZengWileyEcosphere2150-89252021-08-01128n/an/a10.1002/ecs2.3685Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific callsH. Bailey0A. D. Fandel1K. Silva2E. Gryzb3E. McDonald4A. L. Hoover5M. B. Ogburn6A. N. Rice7Chesapeake Biological Laboratory University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science Solomons Maryland 20688 USAChesapeake Biological Laboratory University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science Solomons Maryland 20688 USAChesapeake Biological Laboratory University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science Solomons Maryland 20688 USAChesapeake Biological Laboratory University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science Solomons Maryland 20688 USAChesapeake Biological Laboratory University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science Solomons Maryland 20688 USAChesapeake Biological Laboratory University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science Solomons Maryland 20688 USASmithsonian Environmental Research Center 647 Contees Wharf Road Edgewater Maryland 21037 USACenter for Conservation Bioacoustics Cornell Lab of Ornithology Cornell University Ithaca New York 14850 USAAbstract Passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) offers opportunities to collect data on the occurrence of vocal species for long periods of time, at multiple locations, and under a range of environmental conditions. Some species emit individually distinctive calls, including bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) that produce signature whistles. Our study used PAM to determine the seasonal occurrence of bottlenose dolphins and utilized individually specific signature whistles to (1) track individuals spatially and temporally, (2) assess site fidelity off Maryland (MD), USA, (3) estimate the minimum abundance of dolphins in the study area, and (4) develop a dynamic habitat‐based relative abundance model applicable as a real‐time dolphin relative abundance prediction tool. Acoustic recorders were deployed at two sites offshore of Ocean City, MD, and at one site in the upper Chesapeake Bay, MD. Acoustic recordings from 2016 to 2018 were analyzed for signature whistles, and re‐occurrences of individual whistles were identified using a combination of machine learning and manual verification. A habitat‐based density model was created using the number of signature whistles combined with environmental conditions. A total of 1518 unique signature whistles were identified offshore of Maryland and in the upper Chesapeake Bay. There were 184 re‐occurrences of 142 whistles, with a mean of 135 d between re‐occurrences (range = 1–681 d). These repeated detections of the same individuals occurred most frequently at the site near Ocean City, MD, indicating the highest site fidelity. Re‐occurrences were recorded among all three sites, indicating movement of dolphins between the Chesapeake Bay and off the Atlantic coast of Maryland. The weekly number of individual dolphins detected off the Atlantic coast was significantly related to two environmental variables: sea surface temperature and chlorophyll a concentration. This habitat model could be used to predict relative dolphin abundance offshore of Maryland and inform management within the region, including in relation to offshore wind energy development and other stakeholders.https://doi.org/10.1002/ecs2.3685acoustic communicationbottlenose dolphinsdensity estimationindividual recognitionsignature whistlespecies distribution modeling
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author H. Bailey
A. D. Fandel
K. Silva
E. Gryzb
E. McDonald
A. L. Hoover
M. B. Ogburn
A. N. Rice
spellingShingle H. Bailey
A. D. Fandel
K. Silva
E. Gryzb
E. McDonald
A. L. Hoover
M. B. Ogburn
A. N. Rice
Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls
Ecosphere
acoustic communication
bottlenose dolphins
density estimation
individual recognition
signature whistle
species distribution modeling
author_facet H. Bailey
A. D. Fandel
K. Silva
E. Gryzb
E. McDonald
A. L. Hoover
M. B. Ogburn
A. N. Rice
author_sort H. Bailey
title Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls
title_short Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls
title_full Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls
title_fullStr Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls
title_full_unstemmed Identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls
title_sort identifying and predicting occurrence and abundance of a vocal animal species based on individually specific calls
publisher Wiley
series Ecosphere
issn 2150-8925
publishDate 2021-08-01
description Abstract Passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) offers opportunities to collect data on the occurrence of vocal species for long periods of time, at multiple locations, and under a range of environmental conditions. Some species emit individually distinctive calls, including bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) that produce signature whistles. Our study used PAM to determine the seasonal occurrence of bottlenose dolphins and utilized individually specific signature whistles to (1) track individuals spatially and temporally, (2) assess site fidelity off Maryland (MD), USA, (3) estimate the minimum abundance of dolphins in the study area, and (4) develop a dynamic habitat‐based relative abundance model applicable as a real‐time dolphin relative abundance prediction tool. Acoustic recorders were deployed at two sites offshore of Ocean City, MD, and at one site in the upper Chesapeake Bay, MD. Acoustic recordings from 2016 to 2018 were analyzed for signature whistles, and re‐occurrences of individual whistles were identified using a combination of machine learning and manual verification. A habitat‐based density model was created using the number of signature whistles combined with environmental conditions. A total of 1518 unique signature whistles were identified offshore of Maryland and in the upper Chesapeake Bay. There were 184 re‐occurrences of 142 whistles, with a mean of 135 d between re‐occurrences (range = 1–681 d). These repeated detections of the same individuals occurred most frequently at the site near Ocean City, MD, indicating the highest site fidelity. Re‐occurrences were recorded among all three sites, indicating movement of dolphins between the Chesapeake Bay and off the Atlantic coast of Maryland. The weekly number of individual dolphins detected off the Atlantic coast was significantly related to two environmental variables: sea surface temperature and chlorophyll a concentration. This habitat model could be used to predict relative dolphin abundance offshore of Maryland and inform management within the region, including in relation to offshore wind energy development and other stakeholders.
topic acoustic communication
bottlenose dolphins
density estimation
individual recognition
signature whistle
species distribution modeling
url https://doi.org/10.1002/ecs2.3685
work_keys_str_mv AT hbailey identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
AT adfandel identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
AT ksilva identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
AT egryzb identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
AT emcdonald identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
AT alhoover identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
AT mbogburn identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
AT anrice identifyingandpredictingoccurrenceandabundanceofavocalanimalspeciesbasedonindividuallyspecificcalls
_version_ 1721188306298863616