Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide Imaging

Deep learning methods are widely used for medical applications to assist medical doctors in their daily routine. While performances reach expert’s level, interpretability (highlighting how and what a trained model learned and why it makes a specific decision) is the next important challenge that dee...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Antoine Pirovano, Hippolyte Heuberger, Sylvain Berlemont, SaÏd Ladjal, Isabelle Bloch
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-02-01
Series:Machine Learning and Knowledge Extraction
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2504-4990/3/1/12
id doaj-34908cc7e93b4ebe90ddcc0559c18805
record_format Article
spelling doaj-34908cc7e93b4ebe90ddcc0559c188052021-02-23T00:05:52ZengMDPI AGMachine Learning and Knowledge Extraction2504-49902021-02-0131224326210.3390/make3010012Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide ImagingAntoine Pirovano0Hippolyte Heuberger1Sylvain Berlemont2SaÏd Ladjal3Isabelle Bloch4Keen Eye, 75012 Paris, FranceKeen Eye, 75012 Paris, FranceKeen Eye, 75012 Paris, FranceLTCI, Télécom Paris, Institut Polytechnique de Paris, 91120 Palaiseau, FranceLTCI, Télécom Paris, Institut Polytechnique de Paris, 91120 Palaiseau, FranceDeep learning methods are widely used for medical applications to assist medical doctors in their daily routine. While performances reach expert’s level, interpretability (highlighting how and what a trained model learned and why it makes a specific decision) is the next important challenge that deep learning methods need to answer to be fully integrated in the medical field. In this paper, we address the question of interpretability in the context of whole slide images (WSI) classification with the formalization of the design of WSI classification architectures and propose a piece-wise interpretability approach, relying on gradient-based methods, feature visualization and multiple instance learning context. After training two WSI classification architectures on Camelyon-16 WSI dataset, highlighting discriminative features learned, and validating our approach with pathologists, we propose a novel manner of computing interpretability slide-level heat-maps, based on the extracted features, that improves tile-level classification performances. We measure the improvement using the tile-level AUC that we called Localization AUC, and show an improvement of more than 0.2. We also validate our results with a RemOve And Retrain (ROAR) measure. Then, after studying the impact of the number of features used for heat-map computation, we propose a corrective approach, relying on activation colocalization of selected features, that improves the performances and the stability of our proposed method.https://www.mdpi.com/2504-4990/3/1/12histopathologyWSI classificationexplainabilityinterpretabilityheat-maps
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Antoine Pirovano
Hippolyte Heuberger
Sylvain Berlemont
SaÏd Ladjal
Isabelle Bloch
spellingShingle Antoine Pirovano
Hippolyte Heuberger
Sylvain Berlemont
SaÏd Ladjal
Isabelle Bloch
Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide Imaging
Machine Learning and Knowledge Extraction
histopathology
WSI classification
explainability
interpretability
heat-maps
author_facet Antoine Pirovano
Hippolyte Heuberger
Sylvain Berlemont
SaÏd Ladjal
Isabelle Bloch
author_sort Antoine Pirovano
title Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide Imaging
title_short Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide Imaging
title_full Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide Imaging
title_fullStr Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide Imaging
title_full_unstemmed Automatic Feature Selection for Improved Interpretability on Whole Slide Imaging
title_sort automatic feature selection for improved interpretability on whole slide imaging
publisher MDPI AG
series Machine Learning and Knowledge Extraction
issn 2504-4990
publishDate 2021-02-01
description Deep learning methods are widely used for medical applications to assist medical doctors in their daily routine. While performances reach expert’s level, interpretability (highlighting how and what a trained model learned and why it makes a specific decision) is the next important challenge that deep learning methods need to answer to be fully integrated in the medical field. In this paper, we address the question of interpretability in the context of whole slide images (WSI) classification with the formalization of the design of WSI classification architectures and propose a piece-wise interpretability approach, relying on gradient-based methods, feature visualization and multiple instance learning context. After training two WSI classification architectures on Camelyon-16 WSI dataset, highlighting discriminative features learned, and validating our approach with pathologists, we propose a novel manner of computing interpretability slide-level heat-maps, based on the extracted features, that improves tile-level classification performances. We measure the improvement using the tile-level AUC that we called Localization AUC, and show an improvement of more than 0.2. We also validate our results with a RemOve And Retrain (ROAR) measure. Then, after studying the impact of the number of features used for heat-map computation, we propose a corrective approach, relying on activation colocalization of selected features, that improves the performances and the stability of our proposed method.
topic histopathology
WSI classification
explainability
interpretability
heat-maps
url https://www.mdpi.com/2504-4990/3/1/12
work_keys_str_mv AT antoinepirovano automaticfeatureselectionforimprovedinterpretabilityonwholeslideimaging
AT hippolyteheuberger automaticfeatureselectionforimprovedinterpretabilityonwholeslideimaging
AT sylvainberlemont automaticfeatureselectionforimprovedinterpretabilityonwholeslideimaging
AT saidladjal automaticfeatureselectionforimprovedinterpretabilityonwholeslideimaging
AT isabellebloch automaticfeatureselectionforimprovedinterpretabilityonwholeslideimaging
_version_ 1724255234227699712