A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trial

Abstract Precision oncology is currently based on pairing molecularly targeted agents (MTA) to predefined single driver genes or biomarkers. Each tumor harbors a combination of a large number of potential genetic alterations of multiple driver genes in a complex system that limits the potential of t...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Istvan Petak, Maud Kamal, Anna Dirner, Ivan Bieche, Robert Doczi, Odette Mariani, Peter Filotas, Anne Salomon, Barbara Vodicska, Vincent Servois, Edit Varkondi, David Gentien, Dora Tihanyi, Patricia Tresca, Dora Lakatos, Nicolas Servant, Julia Deri, Pauline du Rusquec, Csilla Hegedus, Diana Bello Roufai, Richard Schwab, Celia Dupain, Istvan T. Valyi-Nagy, Christophe Le Tourneau
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Nature Publishing Group 2021-06-01
Series:npj Precision Oncology
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1038/s41698-021-00191-2
id doaj-25368c6568c249e3961734d462c71641
record_format Article
spelling doaj-25368c6568c249e3961734d462c716412021-06-27T11:09:20ZengNature Publishing Groupnpj Precision Oncology2397-768X2021-06-015111110.1038/s41698-021-00191-2A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trialIstvan Petak0Maud Kamal1Anna Dirner2Ivan Bieche3Robert Doczi4Odette Mariani5Peter Filotas6Anne Salomon7Barbara Vodicska8Vincent Servois9Edit Varkondi10David Gentien11Dora Tihanyi12Patricia Tresca13Dora Lakatos14Nicolas Servant15Julia Deri16Pauline du Rusquec17Csilla Hegedus18Diana Bello Roufai19Richard Schwab20Celia Dupain21Istvan T. Valyi-Nagy22Christophe Le Tourneau23Department of Pharmacology and Pharmacotherapy, Semmelweis UniversityDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation (D3i), Institute CurieOncompass MedicinePharmacogenomics unit, Institut CurieOncompass MedicineDepartment of Biopathology, Institut CurieOncompass MedicineDepartment of Biopathology, Institut CurieOncompass MedicineDepartment of Radiology, Institut CurieOncompass MedicineTranslational Research Department, Institut CurieOncompass MedicineDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation (D3i), Institute CurieOncompass MedicineINSERM U900 Research UnitOncompass MedicineDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation (D3i), Institute CurieOncompass MedicineDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation (D3i), Institute CurieOncompass MedicineDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation (D3i), Institute CurieCentral Hospital of Southern Pest—National Institute for Hematology and Infectious DiseasesDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation (D3i), Institute CurieAbstract Precision oncology is currently based on pairing molecularly targeted agents (MTA) to predefined single driver genes or biomarkers. Each tumor harbors a combination of a large number of potential genetic alterations of multiple driver genes in a complex system that limits the potential of this approach. We have developed an artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted computational method, the digital drug-assignment (DDA) system, to prioritize potential MTAs for each cancer patient based on the complex individual molecular profile of their tumor. We analyzed the clinical benefit of the DDA system on the molecular and clinical outcome data of patients treated in the SHIVA01 precision oncology clinical trial with MTAs matched to individual genetic alterations or biomarkers of their tumor. We found that the DDA score assigned to MTAs was significantly higher in patients experiencing disease control than in patients with progressive disease (1523 versus 580, P = 0.037). The median PFS was also significantly longer in patients receiving MTAs with high (1000+ <) than with low (<0) DDA scores (3.95 versus 1.95 months, P = 0.044). Our results indicate that AI-based systems, like DDA, are promising new tools for oncologists to improve the clinical benefit of precision oncology.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41698-021-00191-2
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Istvan Petak
Maud Kamal
Anna Dirner
Ivan Bieche
Robert Doczi
Odette Mariani
Peter Filotas
Anne Salomon
Barbara Vodicska
Vincent Servois
Edit Varkondi
David Gentien
Dora Tihanyi
Patricia Tresca
Dora Lakatos
Nicolas Servant
Julia Deri
Pauline du Rusquec
Csilla Hegedus
Diana Bello Roufai
Richard Schwab
Celia Dupain
Istvan T. Valyi-Nagy
Christophe Le Tourneau
spellingShingle Istvan Petak
Maud Kamal
Anna Dirner
Ivan Bieche
Robert Doczi
Odette Mariani
Peter Filotas
Anne Salomon
Barbara Vodicska
Vincent Servois
Edit Varkondi
David Gentien
Dora Tihanyi
Patricia Tresca
Dora Lakatos
Nicolas Servant
Julia Deri
Pauline du Rusquec
Csilla Hegedus
Diana Bello Roufai
Richard Schwab
Celia Dupain
Istvan T. Valyi-Nagy
Christophe Le Tourneau
A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trial
npj Precision Oncology
author_facet Istvan Petak
Maud Kamal
Anna Dirner
Ivan Bieche
Robert Doczi
Odette Mariani
Peter Filotas
Anne Salomon
Barbara Vodicska
Vincent Servois
Edit Varkondi
David Gentien
Dora Tihanyi
Patricia Tresca
Dora Lakatos
Nicolas Servant
Julia Deri
Pauline du Rusquec
Csilla Hegedus
Diana Bello Roufai
Richard Schwab
Celia Dupain
Istvan T. Valyi-Nagy
Christophe Le Tourneau
author_sort Istvan Petak
title A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trial
title_short A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trial
title_full A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trial
title_fullStr A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trial
title_full_unstemmed A computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the SHIVA01 trial
title_sort computational method for prioritizing targeted therapies in precision oncology: performance analysis in the shiva01 trial
publisher Nature Publishing Group
series npj Precision Oncology
issn 2397-768X
publishDate 2021-06-01
description Abstract Precision oncology is currently based on pairing molecularly targeted agents (MTA) to predefined single driver genes or biomarkers. Each tumor harbors a combination of a large number of potential genetic alterations of multiple driver genes in a complex system that limits the potential of this approach. We have developed an artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted computational method, the digital drug-assignment (DDA) system, to prioritize potential MTAs for each cancer patient based on the complex individual molecular profile of their tumor. We analyzed the clinical benefit of the DDA system on the molecular and clinical outcome data of patients treated in the SHIVA01 precision oncology clinical trial with MTAs matched to individual genetic alterations or biomarkers of their tumor. We found that the DDA score assigned to MTAs was significantly higher in patients experiencing disease control than in patients with progressive disease (1523 versus 580, P = 0.037). The median PFS was also significantly longer in patients receiving MTAs with high (1000+ <) than with low (<0) DDA scores (3.95 versus 1.95 months, P = 0.044). Our results indicate that AI-based systems, like DDA, are promising new tools for oncologists to improve the clinical benefit of precision oncology.
url https://doi.org/10.1038/s41698-021-00191-2
work_keys_str_mv AT istvanpetak acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT maudkamal acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT annadirner acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT ivanbieche acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT robertdoczi acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT odettemariani acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT peterfilotas acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT annesalomon acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT barbaravodicska acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT vincentservois acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT editvarkondi acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT davidgentien acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT doratihanyi acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT patriciatresca acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT doralakatos acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT nicolasservant acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT juliaderi acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT paulinedurusquec acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT csillahegedus acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT dianabelloroufai acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT richardschwab acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT celiadupain acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT istvantvalyinagy acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT christopheletourneau acomputationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT istvanpetak computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT maudkamal computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT annadirner computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT ivanbieche computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT robertdoczi computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT odettemariani computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT peterfilotas computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT annesalomon computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT barbaravodicska computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT vincentservois computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT editvarkondi computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT davidgentien computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT doratihanyi computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT patriciatresca computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT doralakatos computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT nicolasservant computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT juliaderi computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT paulinedurusquec computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT csillahegedus computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT dianabelloroufai computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT richardschwab computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT celiadupain computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT istvantvalyinagy computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
AT christopheletourneau computationalmethodforprioritizingtargetedtherapiesinprecisiononcologyperformanceanalysisintheshiva01trial
_version_ 1721358101514289152