Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods
<p>The objective of this study was to predict cows' body weight from body size measurements and other animal data in the lactation and dry periods. During the whole year 2014, 6306 cows (on 167 commercial Austrian dairy farms) were weighed at each routine performance recording and bod...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Copernicus Publications
2018-10-01
|
Series: | Archives Animal Breeding |
Online Access: | https://www.arch-anim-breed.net/61/413/2018/aab-61-413-2018.pdf |
id |
doaj-21d649f7a9c6414dbd8f363f5873d7ea |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-21d649f7a9c6414dbd8f363f5873d7ea2020-11-25T00:57:27ZengCopernicus PublicationsArchives Animal Breeding0003-94382363-98222018-10-016141342410.5194/aab-61-413-2018Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periodsL. Gruber0L. Gruber1M. Ledinek2M. Ledinek3F. Steininger4B. Fuerst-Waltl5K. Zottl6M. Royer7K. Krimberger8M. Mayerhofer9C. Egger-Danner10Agricultural Research and Education Centre Raumberg-Gumpenstein, Irdning-Donnersbachtal, 8952, AustriaThese authors contributed equally to this work.Department of Sustainable Agricultural Systems, BOKU – University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Vienna, Vienna, 1180, AustriaThese authors contributed equally to this work.ZuchtData EDV-Dienstleistungen GmbH, Vienna, 1200, AustriaDepartment of Sustainable Agricultural Systems, BOKU – University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Vienna, Vienna, 1180, AustriaLKV Niederösterreich, Zwettl, 3910, AustriaAgricultural Research and Education Centre Raumberg-Gumpenstein, Irdning-Donnersbachtal, 8952, AustriaAgricultural Research and Education Centre Raumberg-Gumpenstein, Irdning-Donnersbachtal, 8952, AustriaZuchtData EDV-Dienstleistungen GmbH, Vienna, 1200, AustriaZuchtData EDV-Dienstleistungen GmbH, Vienna, 1200, Austria<p>The objective of this study was to predict cows' body weight from body size measurements and other animal data in the lactation and dry periods. During the whole year 2014, 6306 cows (on 167 commercial Austrian dairy farms) were weighed at each routine performance recording and body size measurements like heart girth (HG), belly girth (BG), and body condition score (BCS) were recorded. Data on linear traits like hip width (HW), stature, and body depth were collected three times a year. Cows belonged to the genotypes Fleckvieh (and Red Holstein crosses), Holstein, and Brown Swiss. Body measurements were tested as single predictors and in multiple regressions according to their prediction accuracy and their correlations with body weight. For validation, data sets were split randomly into independent subsets for estimation and validation. Within the prediction models with a single body measurement, heart girth influenced relationship with body weight most, with a lowest root mean square error (RMSE) of 39.0 kg, followed by belly girth (39.3 kg) and hip width (49.9 kg). All other body measurements and BCS resulted in a RMSE of higher than 50.0 kg. The model with heart and belly girth (Model<sub>HG BG</sub>) reduced RMSE to 32.5 kg, and adding HW reduced it further to 30.4 kg (Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>). As RMSE and the coefficient of determination improved, genotype-specific regression coefficients for body measurements were introduced in addition to the pooled ones. The most accurate equations, Model<sub>HG BG</sub> and Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>, were validated separately for the lactation and dry periods. Root mean square prediction error (RMSPE) ranged between 36.5 and 37.0 kg (Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>, Model<sub>HG BG</sub>, lactation) and 39.9 and 41.3 kg (Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>, Model<sub>HG BG</sub>, dry period). Accuracy of the predictions was evaluated by decomposing the mean square prediction error (MSPE) into error due to central tendency, error due to regression, and error due to disturbance. On average, 99.6 % of the variance between estimated and observed values was caused by disturbance, meaning that predictions were valid and without systematic estimation error. On the one hand, this indicates that the chosen traits sufficiently depicted factors influencing body weight. On the other hand, the data set was very heterogeneous and large. To ensure high prediction accuracy, it was necessary to include body girth traits for body weight estimation.</p>https://www.arch-anim-breed.net/61/413/2018/aab-61-413-2018.pdf |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
L. Gruber L. Gruber M. Ledinek M. Ledinek F. Steininger B. Fuerst-Waltl K. Zottl M. Royer K. Krimberger M. Mayerhofer C. Egger-Danner |
spellingShingle |
L. Gruber L. Gruber M. Ledinek M. Ledinek F. Steininger B. Fuerst-Waltl K. Zottl M. Royer K. Krimberger M. Mayerhofer C. Egger-Danner Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods Archives Animal Breeding |
author_facet |
L. Gruber L. Gruber M. Ledinek M. Ledinek F. Steininger B. Fuerst-Waltl K. Zottl M. Royer K. Krimberger M. Mayerhofer C. Egger-Danner |
author_sort |
L. Gruber |
title |
Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods |
title_short |
Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods |
title_full |
Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods |
title_fullStr |
Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods |
title_full_unstemmed |
Body weight prediction using body size measurements in Fleckvieh, Holstein, and Brown Swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods |
title_sort |
body weight prediction using body size measurements in fleckvieh, holstein, and brown swiss dairy cows in lactation and dry periods |
publisher |
Copernicus Publications |
series |
Archives Animal Breeding |
issn |
0003-9438 2363-9822 |
publishDate |
2018-10-01 |
description |
<p>The objective of this study was to predict cows'
body weight from body size measurements and other animal data in the
lactation and dry periods. During the whole year 2014, 6306 cows (on
167 commercial Austrian dairy farms) were weighed at each routine performance
recording and body size measurements like heart girth (HG), belly girth (BG),
and body condition score (BCS) were recorded. Data on linear traits like hip
width (HW), stature, and body depth were collected three times a year. Cows
belonged to the genotypes Fleckvieh (and Red Holstein crosses), Holstein, and
Brown Swiss. Body measurements were tested as single predictors and in
multiple regressions according to their prediction accuracy and their
correlations with body weight. For validation, data sets were split randomly
into independent subsets for estimation and validation. Within the prediction
models with a single body measurement, heart girth influenced relationship
with body weight most, with a lowest root mean square error (RMSE) of
39.0 kg, followed by belly girth (39.3 kg) and hip width (49.9 kg). All
other body measurements and BCS resulted in a RMSE of higher than 50.0 kg.
The model with heart and belly girth (Model<sub>HG BG</sub>) reduced RMSE to
32.5 kg, and adding HW reduced it further to
30.4 kg (Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>). As RMSE and the coefficient of
determination improved, genotype-specific regression coefficients for body
measurements were introduced in addition to the pooled ones. The most
accurate equations, Model<sub>HG BG</sub> and Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>,
were validated separately for the lactation and dry periods. Root mean square
prediction error (RMSPE) ranged between 36.5 and 37.0 kg
(Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>, Model<sub>HG BG</sub>, lactation) and 39.9 and
41.3 kg (Model<sub>HG BG HW</sub>, Model<sub>HG BG</sub>, dry period).
Accuracy of the predictions was evaluated by decomposing the mean square
prediction error (MSPE) into error due to central tendency, error due to
regression, and error due to disturbance. On average, 99.6 % of the
variance between estimated and observed values was caused by disturbance,
meaning that predictions were valid and without systematic estimation error.
On the one hand, this indicates that the chosen traits sufficiently depicted
factors influencing body weight. On the other hand, the data set was very
heterogeneous and large. To ensure high prediction accuracy, it was necessary
to include body girth traits for body weight estimation.</p> |
url |
https://www.arch-anim-breed.net/61/413/2018/aab-61-413-2018.pdf |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT lgruber bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT lgruber bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT mledinek bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT mledinek bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT fsteininger bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT bfuerstwaltl bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT kzottl bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT mroyer bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT kkrimberger bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT mmayerhofer bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods AT ceggerdanner bodyweightpredictionusingbodysizemeasurementsinfleckviehholsteinandbrownswissdairycowsinlactationanddryperiods |
_version_ |
1725224189108944896 |