Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experience

Abstract Introduction Methanol poisoning usually occurs in a cluster and initial diagnosis can be challenging. Mortality is high without immediate interventions. This paper describes a methanol poisoning outbreak and difficulties in managing a large number of patients with limited resources. Methodo...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: J. Md Noor, R. Hawari, M. F. Mokhtar, S. J. Yussof, N. Chew, N. A. Norzan, R. Rahimi, Z. Ismail, S. Singh, J. Baladas, N. H. Hashim, M. I. K. Mohamad, M. D. Pathmanathan
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2020-02-01
Series:International Journal of Emergency Medicine
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1186/s12245-020-0264-5
id doaj-20d453e6d2fc43459aea1dda7c116257
record_format Article
spelling doaj-20d453e6d2fc43459aea1dda7c1162572021-02-07T12:19:40ZengBMCInternational Journal of Emergency Medicine1865-13721865-13802020-02-011311710.1186/s12245-020-0264-5Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experienceJ. Md Noor0R. Hawari1M. F. Mokhtar2S. J. Yussof3N. Chew4N. A. Norzan5R. Rahimi6Z. Ismail7S. Singh8J. Baladas9N. H. Hashim10M. I. K. Mohamad11M. D. Pathmanathan12Emergency Department, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Jalan HospitalEmergency & Trauma Department, Hospital Sg Buloh, Jalan HospitalEmergency Department, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Jalan HospitalEmergency & Trauma Department, Hospital Sg Buloh, Jalan HospitalEmergency & Trauma Department, Hospital Sg Buloh, Jalan HospitalEmergency & Trauma Department, Hospital Sg Buloh, Jalan HospitalDepartment of Pathology, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Jalan HospitalDepartment of Public Health & Preventative Medicine, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Jalan HospitalEmergency & Trauma Department, Hospital Sg Buloh, Jalan HospitalEmergency & Trauma Department, Hospital Sg Buloh, Jalan HospitalEmergency & Trauma Department, Hospital Sg Buloh, Jalan HospitalEmergency Department, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Jalan HospitalNational Institute of HealthAbstract Introduction Methanol poisoning usually occurs in a cluster and initial diagnosis can be challenging. Mortality is high without immediate interventions. This paper describes a methanol poisoning outbreak and difficulties in managing a large number of patients with limited resources. Methodology A retrospective analysis of a methanol poisoning outbreak in September 2018 was performed, describing patients who presented to a major tertiary referral centre. Result A total of 31 patients were received over the period of 9 days. Thirty of them were males with a mean age of 32 years old. They were mostly foreigners. From the 31 patients, 19.3% were dead on arrival, 3.2% died in the emergency department and 38.7% survived and discharged. The overall mortality rate was 61.3%. Out of the 12 patients who survived, two patients had toxic optic neuropathy, and one patient had uveitis. The rest of the survivors did not have any long-term complications. Osmolar gap and lactate had strong correlations with patient’s mortality. Serum pH, bicarbonate, lactate, potassium, anion gap, osmolar gap and measured serum osmolarity between the alive and dead patients were significant. Post-mortem findings of the brain were unremarkable. Conclusion The mortality rate was higher, and the morbidity includes permanent visual impairment and severe neurological sequelae. Language barrier, severity of illness, late presentation, unavailability of intravenous ethanol and fomipezole and delayed dialysis may have been the contributing factors. Patient was managed based on clinical presentation. Laboratory parameters showed difference in median between group that survived and succumbed for pH, serum bicarbonate, lactate, potassium and osmolar and anion gap. Management of methanol toxicity outbreak in resource-limited area will benefit from a well-designed guideline that is adaptable to the locality.https://doi.org/10.1186/s12245-020-0264-5MethanolToxicityPoisoningOutbreakDialysis
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author J. Md Noor
R. Hawari
M. F. Mokhtar
S. J. Yussof
N. Chew
N. A. Norzan
R. Rahimi
Z. Ismail
S. Singh
J. Baladas
N. H. Hashim
M. I. K. Mohamad
M. D. Pathmanathan
spellingShingle J. Md Noor
R. Hawari
M. F. Mokhtar
S. J. Yussof
N. Chew
N. A. Norzan
R. Rahimi
Z. Ismail
S. Singh
J. Baladas
N. H. Hashim
M. I. K. Mohamad
M. D. Pathmanathan
Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experience
International Journal of Emergency Medicine
Methanol
Toxicity
Poisoning
Outbreak
Dialysis
author_facet J. Md Noor
R. Hawari
M. F. Mokhtar
S. J. Yussof
N. Chew
N. A. Norzan
R. Rahimi
Z. Ismail
S. Singh
J. Baladas
N. H. Hashim
M. I. K. Mohamad
M. D. Pathmanathan
author_sort J. Md Noor
title Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experience
title_short Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experience
title_full Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experience
title_fullStr Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experience
title_full_unstemmed Methanol outbreak: a Malaysian tertiary hospital experience
title_sort methanol outbreak: a malaysian tertiary hospital experience
publisher BMC
series International Journal of Emergency Medicine
issn 1865-1372
1865-1380
publishDate 2020-02-01
description Abstract Introduction Methanol poisoning usually occurs in a cluster and initial diagnosis can be challenging. Mortality is high without immediate interventions. This paper describes a methanol poisoning outbreak and difficulties in managing a large number of patients with limited resources. Methodology A retrospective analysis of a methanol poisoning outbreak in September 2018 was performed, describing patients who presented to a major tertiary referral centre. Result A total of 31 patients were received over the period of 9 days. Thirty of them were males with a mean age of 32 years old. They were mostly foreigners. From the 31 patients, 19.3% were dead on arrival, 3.2% died in the emergency department and 38.7% survived and discharged. The overall mortality rate was 61.3%. Out of the 12 patients who survived, two patients had toxic optic neuropathy, and one patient had uveitis. The rest of the survivors did not have any long-term complications. Osmolar gap and lactate had strong correlations with patient’s mortality. Serum pH, bicarbonate, lactate, potassium, anion gap, osmolar gap and measured serum osmolarity between the alive and dead patients were significant. Post-mortem findings of the brain were unremarkable. Conclusion The mortality rate was higher, and the morbidity includes permanent visual impairment and severe neurological sequelae. Language barrier, severity of illness, late presentation, unavailability of intravenous ethanol and fomipezole and delayed dialysis may have been the contributing factors. Patient was managed based on clinical presentation. Laboratory parameters showed difference in median between group that survived and succumbed for pH, serum bicarbonate, lactate, potassium and osmolar and anion gap. Management of methanol toxicity outbreak in resource-limited area will benefit from a well-designed guideline that is adaptable to the locality.
topic Methanol
Toxicity
Poisoning
Outbreak
Dialysis
url https://doi.org/10.1186/s12245-020-0264-5
work_keys_str_mv AT jmdnoor methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT rhawari methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT mfmokhtar methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT sjyussof methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT nchew methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT nanorzan methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT rrahimi methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT zismail methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT ssingh methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT jbaladas methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT nhhashim methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT mikmohamad methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
AT mdpathmanathan methanoloutbreakamalaysiantertiaryhospitalexperience
_version_ 1724281306278264832