Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of Lithuania

Aim: This study aimed to explore and describe the barriers that elderly Lithuanians experience with respect to going to court or other institutions to defend their right not to be discriminated regarding medical care. Methods: We used a mixed methods approach due to the scarcity of information in L...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Kristina Selli, Kasia Czabanowska, Lina Danusevičienė, Rūta Butkevičienė, Ramunė Jurkuvienė, Judy Overall
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Jacobs Verlag 2016-07-01
Series:South Eastern European Journal of Public Health
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.seejph.com/index.php/seejph/article/view/124
id doaj-1e93c0efdf7c46bc8c488aae9979e053
record_format Article
spelling doaj-1e93c0efdf7c46bc8c488aae9979e0532020-11-25T01:12:56ZengJacobs VerlagSouth Eastern European Journal of Public Health2197-52482016-07-016110.4119/UNIBI/SEEJPH-2016-12486Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of LithuaniaKristina SelliKasia CzabanowskaLina DanusevičienėRūta ButkevičienėRamunė JurkuvienėJudy OverallAim: This study aimed to explore and describe the barriers that elderly Lithuanians experience with respect to going to court or other institutions to defend their right not to be discriminated regarding medical care. Methods: We used a mixed methods approach due to the scarcity of information in Lithuania. First, the review of laws was done using the e-tar database and court cases were searched using the e-teismai database followed by policy analysis. Additional sources of information were identified searching Google Scholar and PubMed, as well as Google for grey literature. The keywords used were: ageism in patient care, discrimination against elderly, elderly and health (English and Lithuanian: 2000-2015). Secondly, we conducted in-depth individual interviews with 27 clients of newly-established integrated home care services: 13 elderly patients, and 14 informal caregivers. Results:  This study identified five groups of barriers explaining why Lithuanian elderly are hesitant to fight discrimination in the health system. The results of the study disclose the following barriers that the elderly in Lithuania face: i) the lack of recognition of the phenomenon of discrimination against the elderly in patient care; ii) the lack of information for complaining and the fear of consequences of complaining; iii) the deficiencies and uncertainties of laws and regulations devoted to discrimination; iv) the high level of burden of proof in court cases and lack of good practices; v) the lack of a patient (human) rights-based approach in all policies and in education as well as the lack of intersectoral work. Conclusions:  This study disclosed the need to: encourage training of legists and lawyers in expanding knowledge and skills in human rights in patient care;  encourage training of health care professionals – the burden of leadership for this has to be assumed by universities and public health professionals; incorporate a new article in the ‘Law on the rights of patients and compensation for the damage to their health’, clearly stating where to complain in case of discrimination; create a webpage and brochures with readable and understandable information for elderly persons and their families and caregivers; establish legal consultation and mediation cabinets in health care facilities; establish an older persons’ rights protection service under the Ministry of Social Security and Labour in close cooperation with the Ministry of Health; promote sustainable results by incorporating a human rights-based approach regarding elderly persons in all policies.http://www.seejph.com/index.php/seejph/article/view/124aging, discrimination against elderly patients, human rights, legislation, Lithuania, patient care.
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Kristina Selli
Kasia Czabanowska
Lina Danusevičienė
Rūta Butkevičienė
Ramunė Jurkuvienė
Judy Overall
spellingShingle Kristina Selli
Kasia Czabanowska
Lina Danusevičienė
Rūta Butkevičienė
Ramunė Jurkuvienė
Judy Overall
Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of Lithuania
South Eastern European Journal of Public Health
aging, discrimination against elderly patients, human rights, legislation, Lithuania, patient care.
author_facet Kristina Selli
Kasia Czabanowska
Lina Danusevičienė
Rūta Butkevičienė
Ramunė Jurkuvienė
Judy Overall
author_sort Kristina Selli
title Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of Lithuania
title_short Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of Lithuania
title_full Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of Lithuania
title_fullStr Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of Lithuania
title_full_unstemmed Discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of Lithuania
title_sort discrimination of elderly patients in the health care system of lithuania
publisher Jacobs Verlag
series South Eastern European Journal of Public Health
issn 2197-5248
publishDate 2016-07-01
description Aim: This study aimed to explore and describe the barriers that elderly Lithuanians experience with respect to going to court or other institutions to defend their right not to be discriminated regarding medical care. Methods: We used a mixed methods approach due to the scarcity of information in Lithuania. First, the review of laws was done using the e-tar database and court cases were searched using the e-teismai database followed by policy analysis. Additional sources of information were identified searching Google Scholar and PubMed, as well as Google for grey literature. The keywords used were: ageism in patient care, discrimination against elderly, elderly and health (English and Lithuanian: 2000-2015). Secondly, we conducted in-depth individual interviews with 27 clients of newly-established integrated home care services: 13 elderly patients, and 14 informal caregivers. Results:  This study identified five groups of barriers explaining why Lithuanian elderly are hesitant to fight discrimination in the health system. The results of the study disclose the following barriers that the elderly in Lithuania face: i) the lack of recognition of the phenomenon of discrimination against the elderly in patient care; ii) the lack of information for complaining and the fear of consequences of complaining; iii) the deficiencies and uncertainties of laws and regulations devoted to discrimination; iv) the high level of burden of proof in court cases and lack of good practices; v) the lack of a patient (human) rights-based approach in all policies and in education as well as the lack of intersectoral work. Conclusions:  This study disclosed the need to: encourage training of legists and lawyers in expanding knowledge and skills in human rights in patient care;  encourage training of health care professionals – the burden of leadership for this has to be assumed by universities and public health professionals; incorporate a new article in the ‘Law on the rights of patients and compensation for the damage to their health’, clearly stating where to complain in case of discrimination; create a webpage and brochures with readable and understandable information for elderly persons and their families and caregivers; establish legal consultation and mediation cabinets in health care facilities; establish an older persons’ rights protection service under the Ministry of Social Security and Labour in close cooperation with the Ministry of Health; promote sustainable results by incorporating a human rights-based approach regarding elderly persons in all policies.
topic aging, discrimination against elderly patients, human rights, legislation, Lithuania, patient care.
url http://www.seejph.com/index.php/seejph/article/view/124
work_keys_str_mv AT kristinaselli discriminationofelderlypatientsinthehealthcaresystemoflithuania
AT kasiaczabanowska discriminationofelderlypatientsinthehealthcaresystemoflithuania
AT linadanuseviciene discriminationofelderlypatientsinthehealthcaresystemoflithuania
AT rutabutkeviciene discriminationofelderlypatientsinthehealthcaresystemoflithuania
AT ramunejurkuviene discriminationofelderlypatientsinthehealthcaresystemoflithuania
AT judyoverall discriminationofelderlypatientsinthehealthcaresystemoflithuania
_version_ 1725164248146903040