Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean Spanish

<p>Since Cinque’s (2006:31-32) four-way typology of languages in terms of clitic climbing (CC, herein), those in which CC displays optionality, such as Argentinean Spanish (ArgSp, herein), remain poorly understood. This paper aims to address this need. Here, we show that: (i) empirically, CC h...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Ioanna Sitaridou, Helen Whimpanny, Laura Ayres
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona 2015-10-01
Series:Isogloss
Subjects:
Online Access:https://revistes.uab.cat/isogloss/article/view/21
id doaj-17d39e64e0254776832634e9ad518875
record_format Article
spelling doaj-17d39e64e0254776832634e9ad5188752021-05-04T15:59:05ZengUniversitat Autònoma de BarcelonaIsogloss2385-41382015-10-011224729110.5565/rev/isogloss.2116Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean SpanishIoanna Sitaridou0Helen Whimpanny1Laura Ayres2Queens' College, University of CambridgeUniversity of CambridgeUniversity of Cambridge<p>Since Cinque’s (2006:31-32) four-way typology of languages in terms of clitic climbing (CC, herein), those in which CC displays optionality, such as Argentinean Spanish (ArgSp, herein), remain poorly understood. This paper aims to address this need. Here, we show that: (i) empirically, CC has remained a prevalent option in spoken ArgSp since its incipient stage (Davies 1995), yet at the same time we reveal significant diatopic variation in terms of optionality; (ii) theoretically, we capture this optionality partly in terms of ‘parametric hierarchies’ (Biberauer &amp; Roberts 2012) with no considerable impact otherwise on any macro/meso-parameter in this variety. However, in order to fully explain our data, we postulate that the macro-parameter setting makes a Pool of Variants (in the spirit of Adger (2013) and Adger &amp; Smith (2007)) available, in which there are options for CC spell out: proclisis on the matrix or enclisis on the embedded verb(s). Crucially these options do not yield interpretive effects and, therefore, the drive behind the clitic position is lexical. The probability with which one of the clitic spell out positions is selected is claimed to depend at least in part on frequency, behind which we expect a variety of sociolinguistic factors.</p>https://revistes.uab.cat/isogloss/article/view/21clitic climbingargentinean spanishoptionalityisoglossparametric theorypool of variants
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Ioanna Sitaridou
Helen Whimpanny
Laura Ayres
spellingShingle Ioanna Sitaridou
Helen Whimpanny
Laura Ayres
Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean Spanish
Isogloss
clitic climbing
argentinean spanish
optionality
isogloss
parametric theory
pool of variants
author_facet Ioanna Sitaridou
Helen Whimpanny
Laura Ayres
author_sort Ioanna Sitaridou
title Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean Spanish
title_short Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean Spanish
title_full Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean Spanish
title_fullStr Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean Spanish
title_full_unstemmed Variation and optionality in clitic climbing in Argentinean Spanish
title_sort variation and optionality in clitic climbing in argentinean spanish
publisher Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona
series Isogloss
issn 2385-4138
publishDate 2015-10-01
description <p>Since Cinque’s (2006:31-32) four-way typology of languages in terms of clitic climbing (CC, herein), those in which CC displays optionality, such as Argentinean Spanish (ArgSp, herein), remain poorly understood. This paper aims to address this need. Here, we show that: (i) empirically, CC has remained a prevalent option in spoken ArgSp since its incipient stage (Davies 1995), yet at the same time we reveal significant diatopic variation in terms of optionality; (ii) theoretically, we capture this optionality partly in terms of ‘parametric hierarchies’ (Biberauer &amp; Roberts 2012) with no considerable impact otherwise on any macro/meso-parameter in this variety. However, in order to fully explain our data, we postulate that the macro-parameter setting makes a Pool of Variants (in the spirit of Adger (2013) and Adger &amp; Smith (2007)) available, in which there are options for CC spell out: proclisis on the matrix or enclisis on the embedded verb(s). Crucially these options do not yield interpretive effects and, therefore, the drive behind the clitic position is lexical. The probability with which one of the clitic spell out positions is selected is claimed to depend at least in part on frequency, behind which we expect a variety of sociolinguistic factors.</p>
topic clitic climbing
argentinean spanish
optionality
isogloss
parametric theory
pool of variants
url https://revistes.uab.cat/isogloss/article/view/21
work_keys_str_mv AT ioannasitaridou variationandoptionalityincliticclimbinginargentineanspanish
AT helenwhimpanny variationandoptionalityincliticclimbinginargentineanspanish
AT lauraayres variationandoptionalityincliticclimbinginargentineanspanish
_version_ 1721478447601025024