Meaning to multiply: Electrophysiological evidence that children and adults treat multiplication facts differently

• Main Authors: Amandine E. Grenier, Danielle S. Dickson, Corey S. Sparks, Nicole Y.Y. Wicha
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier 2020-12-01
• Series: Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience
• Subjects: N400; Multiplication; Arithmetic; Language; Children; Adults
• Online Access: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1878929320301237

Multiplication tables are typically memorized verbally, with fluent retrieval leading to better performance in advanced math. Arithmetic development is characterized by strategy shifts from procedural operations to direct fact retrieval, which would not necessitate access to the facts’ conceptual meaning. This study tested this hypothesis using a combination of event related brain potentials (ERP) and behavioral measures with 3rd-5th grade children and young adults. Participants verified the solutions to simple multiplication problems (2 × 3 = 6 or = 7) and the semantic fit of word-picture pairs, separately. Children showed an N400 effect to multiplication solutions with larger (more negative) amplitude for incorrect than correct solutions, reflecting meaning-level processing. A similar ERP response was observed in the word-picture verification task, with larger negative amplitude for word-picture pairs that were semantically mismatched compared to matched. In contrast, adults showed a P300 response for correct solutions, suggesting that they treated these solutions as potential targets in over-rehearsed mathematical expressions. This P300 response was specific to math fact processing, as the word-picture verification task elicited a classic N400 in adults. These ERP findings reveal an overlooked developmental transition that occurs after fifth grade, and speak to theories of arithmetic that have been based primarily on adult data.