Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of Agamben

<p>The aim of this article is a detailed analysis of the critique concerning the concept<br />of subjectivity in Giorgio Agamben’s philosophy made by the Polish philosopher<br />Agata Bielik-Robson arguing for her own conceptualization of subject’s ethical<br />formation. The...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Mikołaj Ratajczak
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Adam Mickiewicz University 2013-01-01
Series:Praktyka Teoretyczna
Subjects:
Online Access:http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/prt/article/view/2935
id doaj-0febec987e4a438194c44f31a11d3d9d
record_format Article
spelling doaj-0febec987e4a438194c44f31a11d3d9d2021-08-02T01:43:57ZengAdam Mickiewicz UniversityPraktyka Teoretyczna2081-81302013-01-018234736310.14746/prt.2013.2.162906Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of AgambenMikołaj Ratajczak<p>The aim of this article is a detailed analysis of the critique concerning the concept<br />of subjectivity in Giorgio Agamben’s philosophy made by the Polish philosopher<br />Agata Bielik-Robson arguing for her own conceptualization of subject’s ethical<br />formation. The main thesis states that by situating Agamben in the conceptual<br />horizon he aims to overcome, her critique stopped halfway. In doing so, the article<br />shows that the common ground of both Agamben’s and Bielik-Robson’s views on<br />the subject is the philosophy of Hegel and the differences between them can be<br />explicated as the difference in choosing one of two strategies of subject’s formation<br />deriving from Hegel: while Bielik-Robson radicalizes the moment of negativity,<br />Agamben tries to elaborate a different (messianic) logic of Aufhebung.</p>http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/prt/article/view/2935PodmiotnegatywnośćzniesienieAufhebungdésoeuvrementkatargeinmetafizykaetykaGłospraktykaśmierćAgambenBielik- RobsonHegel
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Mikołaj Ratajczak
spellingShingle Mikołaj Ratajczak
Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of Agamben
Praktyka Teoretyczna
Podmiot
negatywność
zniesienie
Aufhebung
désoeuvrement
katargein
metafizyka
etyka
Głos
praktyka
śmierć
Agamben
Bielik- Robson
Hegel
author_facet Mikołaj Ratajczak
author_sort Mikołaj Ratajczak
title Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of Agamben
title_short Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of Agamben
title_full Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of Agamben
title_fullStr Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of Agamben
title_full_unstemmed Subject Between Negativity and Aufhebung/désoeuvrement. Refutation of the Cryptotheological Critique of Agamben
title_sort subject between negativity and aufhebung/désoeuvrement. refutation of the cryptotheological critique of agamben
publisher Adam Mickiewicz University
series Praktyka Teoretyczna
issn 2081-8130
publishDate 2013-01-01
description <p>The aim of this article is a detailed analysis of the critique concerning the concept<br />of subjectivity in Giorgio Agamben’s philosophy made by the Polish philosopher<br />Agata Bielik-Robson arguing for her own conceptualization of subject’s ethical<br />formation. The main thesis states that by situating Agamben in the conceptual<br />horizon he aims to overcome, her critique stopped halfway. In doing so, the article<br />shows that the common ground of both Agamben’s and Bielik-Robson’s views on<br />the subject is the philosophy of Hegel and the differences between them can be<br />explicated as the difference in choosing one of two strategies of subject’s formation<br />deriving from Hegel: while Bielik-Robson radicalizes the moment of negativity,<br />Agamben tries to elaborate a different (messianic) logic of Aufhebung.</p>
topic Podmiot
negatywność
zniesienie
Aufhebung
désoeuvrement
katargein
metafizyka
etyka
Głos
praktyka
śmierć
Agamben
Bielik- Robson
Hegel
url http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/prt/article/view/2935
work_keys_str_mv AT mikołajratajczak subjectbetweennegativityandaufhebungdesoeuvrementrefutationofthecryptotheologicalcritiqueofagamben
_version_ 1721244452867014656