Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political News

Background: This paper seeks to shed some light concerning on evaluative language maintenance and shift at translation phenomenon of online news. Though this translation issue is frequently discussed in academic discourse, little has been concerned on comprehending to what extent the evaluation u...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Ahmad Zakki Maulana, Mangatur Rudolf Nababan, Riyadi Santosa
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Widya Gama Mahakam Samarinda University 2020-10-01
Series:Script Journal
Online Access:https://jurnal.fkip-uwgm.ac.id/index.php/Script/article/view/562
id doaj-0d890c10b25442fe83c62efc8fdc270c
record_format Article
spelling doaj-0d890c10b25442fe83c62efc8fdc270c2021-07-30T03:42:36ZengWidya Gama Mahakam Samarinda UniversityScript Journal2477-18802502-66232020-10-015218119410.24903/sj.v5i2.562562Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political NewsAhmad Zakki Maulana0Mangatur Rudolf Nababan1Riyadi Santosa2Universitas Sebelas MaretSebelas Maret University Sebelas Maret University Background: This paper seeks to shed some light concerning on evaluative language maintenance and shift at translation phenomenon of online news. Though this translation issue is frequently discussed in academic discourse, little has been concerned on comprehending to what extent the evaluation used in political news has been retained of shifted in their target texts. Methodology: Three political news articles published on ‘The Conversation’ online media were selected for the analysis. For doing so, appraisal system and translation technique theory-based concepts were adopted to guide the analysis as well as the discussion. We employed a noteworthy move in terms of data collection technique, that is focus-group discussion by involving a number of experts who are engaged in the field of linguistics and translation studies. Findings: This research findings can be understood as evaluative language maintenance dominating the data compared to translation shift. Translators attempted to bridge Indonesian readers by rendering some ideologically news, with the aim of knocking language distance down between English and Indonesian texts. Meanwhile, a plenty of translation techniques encourage translator awareness to take position upon rendering ideological news, in case of retaining, altering, as well as omitting the constructed meanings. Conclusion: It is pivotal, as a consequence, to increase news translators’ awareness of understanding attitude constructed in political news. Otherwise, there will be reframing phenomena as the cause of translators’ intervention depriving readers’ rights to understand mass media attitude. Keywords: evaluative language; translation; political newshttps://jurnal.fkip-uwgm.ac.id/index.php/Script/article/view/562
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Ahmad Zakki Maulana
Mangatur Rudolf Nababan
Riyadi Santosa
spellingShingle Ahmad Zakki Maulana
Mangatur Rudolf Nababan
Riyadi Santosa
Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political News
Script Journal
author_facet Ahmad Zakki Maulana
Mangatur Rudolf Nababan
Riyadi Santosa
author_sort Ahmad Zakki Maulana
title Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political News
title_short Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political News
title_full Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political News
title_fullStr Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political News
title_full_unstemmed Evaluative Language Maintenance and Shift on Vice-Presidential Candidates Reportage: Translation Analysis of ‘The Conversation’ Political News
title_sort evaluative language maintenance and shift on vice-presidential candidates reportage: translation analysis of ‘the conversation’ political news
publisher Widya Gama Mahakam Samarinda University
series Script Journal
issn 2477-1880
2502-6623
publishDate 2020-10-01
description Background: This paper seeks to shed some light concerning on evaluative language maintenance and shift at translation phenomenon of online news. Though this translation issue is frequently discussed in academic discourse, little has been concerned on comprehending to what extent the evaluation used in political news has been retained of shifted in their target texts. Methodology: Three political news articles published on ‘The Conversation’ online media were selected for the analysis. For doing so, appraisal system and translation technique theory-based concepts were adopted to guide the analysis as well as the discussion. We employed a noteworthy move in terms of data collection technique, that is focus-group discussion by involving a number of experts who are engaged in the field of linguistics and translation studies. Findings: This research findings can be understood as evaluative language maintenance dominating the data compared to translation shift. Translators attempted to bridge Indonesian readers by rendering some ideologically news, with the aim of knocking language distance down between English and Indonesian texts. Meanwhile, a plenty of translation techniques encourage translator awareness to take position upon rendering ideological news, in case of retaining, altering, as well as omitting the constructed meanings. Conclusion: It is pivotal, as a consequence, to increase news translators’ awareness of understanding attitude constructed in political news. Otherwise, there will be reframing phenomena as the cause of translators’ intervention depriving readers’ rights to understand mass media attitude. Keywords: evaluative language; translation; political news
url https://jurnal.fkip-uwgm.ac.id/index.php/Script/article/view/562
work_keys_str_mv AT ahmadzakkimaulana evaluativelanguagemaintenanceandshiftonvicepresidentialcandidatesreportagetranslationanalysisoftheconversationpoliticalnews
AT mangaturrudolfnababan evaluativelanguagemaintenanceandshiftonvicepresidentialcandidatesreportagetranslationanalysisoftheconversationpoliticalnews
AT riyadisantosa evaluativelanguagemaintenanceandshiftonvicepresidentialcandidatesreportagetranslationanalysisoftheconversationpoliticalnews
_version_ 1721247938767749120