Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAM

River discharge data are critical to elaborating on engineering projects and water resources management. Discharge data must be precise and collected with good temporal resolution. To elaborate on a more accurate database, this paper aims to quantify the uncertainty generated while applying Bayesian...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Guilherme da Cruz dos Reis, Tatiane Souza Rodrigues Pereira, Geovanne Silva Faria, Klebber Teodomiro Martins Formiga
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-11-01
Series:Water
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/12/11/3270
id doaj-0b10c88b8cbe48469eb886fff081e2e7
record_format Article
spelling doaj-0b10c88b8cbe48469eb886fff081e2e72020-11-25T04:05:31ZengMDPI AGWater2073-44412020-11-01123270327010.3390/w12113270Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAMGuilherme da Cruz dos Reis0Tatiane Souza Rodrigues Pereira1Geovanne Silva Faria2Klebber Teodomiro Martins Formiga3Environmental and Sanitary Engineering Postgraduate Program – PPGEAS, School of Civil and Environment Engineering, Federal University of Goias, Universitaria Ave., 1488 – Setor Leste Universitario, Goiania CEP 74605-220, BrazilEnvironmental Engineering, Postgraduate Program CIAMB, Campus Samambaia, Federal University of Goias, Avenue Palmeiras - Farms California, Goiania CEP 74045-155, BrazilEnvironmental and Sanitary Engineering Postgraduate Program – PPGEAS, School of Civil and Environment Engineering, Federal University of Goias, Universitaria Ave., 1488 – Setor Leste Universitario, Goiania CEP 74605-220, BrazilEnvironmental and Sanitary Engineering Postgraduate Program – PPGEAS, School of Civil and Environment Engineering, Federal University of Goias, Universitaria Ave., 1488 – Setor Leste Universitario, Goiania CEP 74605-220, BrazilRiver discharge data are critical to elaborating on engineering projects and water resources management. Discharge data must be precise and collected with good temporal resolution. To elaborate on a more accurate database, this paper aims to quantify the uncertainty generated while applying Bayesian inference through the GLUE and DREAM methods. Both methods were used to estimate hydraulic parameters and compare between them with Manning’s equation. Throughout the statistical analysis, the uncertainties in the application of the models are used to determine the parameters of Manning’s roughness coefficient and bed slope. The validation was made via a comparison of the calculated maximum and minimum discharges, and the observed flow available at HidroWeb. In conclusion, both methods estimated the hydraulic parameters well, but a higher relative deviation was seen in the intervals with smaller calculated discharges; DREAM appears to be more accurate than GLUE, once the relative deviation in GLUE became greater.https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/12/11/3270river dischargestagerating curveBayesian inferenceuncertainty
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Guilherme da Cruz dos Reis
Tatiane Souza Rodrigues Pereira
Geovanne Silva Faria
Klebber Teodomiro Martins Formiga
spellingShingle Guilherme da Cruz dos Reis
Tatiane Souza Rodrigues Pereira
Geovanne Silva Faria
Klebber Teodomiro Martins Formiga
Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAM
Water
river discharge
stage
rating curve
Bayesian inference
uncertainty
author_facet Guilherme da Cruz dos Reis
Tatiane Souza Rodrigues Pereira
Geovanne Silva Faria
Klebber Teodomiro Martins Formiga
author_sort Guilherme da Cruz dos Reis
title Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAM
title_short Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAM
title_full Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAM
title_fullStr Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAM
title_full_unstemmed Analysis of the Uncertainty in Estimates of Manning’s Roughness Coefficient and Bed Slope Using GLUE and DREAM
title_sort analysis of the uncertainty in estimates of manning’s roughness coefficient and bed slope using glue and dream
publisher MDPI AG
series Water
issn 2073-4441
publishDate 2020-11-01
description River discharge data are critical to elaborating on engineering projects and water resources management. Discharge data must be precise and collected with good temporal resolution. To elaborate on a more accurate database, this paper aims to quantify the uncertainty generated while applying Bayesian inference through the GLUE and DREAM methods. Both methods were used to estimate hydraulic parameters and compare between them with Manning’s equation. Throughout the statistical analysis, the uncertainties in the application of the models are used to determine the parameters of Manning’s roughness coefficient and bed slope. The validation was made via a comparison of the calculated maximum and minimum discharges, and the observed flow available at HidroWeb. In conclusion, both methods estimated the hydraulic parameters well, but a higher relative deviation was seen in the intervals with smaller calculated discharges; DREAM appears to be more accurate than GLUE, once the relative deviation in GLUE became greater.
topic river discharge
stage
rating curve
Bayesian inference
uncertainty
url https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/12/11/3270
work_keys_str_mv AT guilhermedacruzdosreis analysisoftheuncertaintyinestimatesofmanningsroughnesscoefficientandbedslopeusingglueanddream
AT tatianesouzarodriguespereira analysisoftheuncertaintyinestimatesofmanningsroughnesscoefficientandbedslopeusingglueanddream
AT geovannesilvafaria analysisoftheuncertaintyinestimatesofmanningsroughnesscoefficientandbedslopeusingglueanddream
AT klebberteodomiromartinsformiga analysisoftheuncertaintyinestimatesofmanningsroughnesscoefficientandbedslopeusingglueanddream
_version_ 1724433495641554944