A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.

BACKGROUND:The T-SPOT.TB can be read by an ELISPOT plate imager as an alternative to a labor-intensive and time-consuming manual reading, but its accuracy has not been sufficiently discussed to date. METHODS:1,423 test results obtained from manual reading using a microscope and an ELISPOT plate imag...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Tae Yeul Kim, Ho Eun Chang, Seong-Wook Lee, Soo Hyun Seo, Yun Ji Hong, Jeong Su Park, Kyoung Un Park
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2019-01-01
Series:PLoS ONE
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0222920
id doaj-09a477ac7ba64613b3c5f7254d3a2b58
record_format Article
spelling doaj-09a477ac7ba64613b3c5f7254d3a2b582021-03-03T21:07:19ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032019-01-01149e022292010.1371/journal.pone.0222920A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.Tae Yeul KimHo Eun ChangSeong-Wook LeeSoo Hyun SeoYun Ji HongJeong Su ParkKyoung Un ParkBACKGROUND:The T-SPOT.TB can be read by an ELISPOT plate imager as an alternative to a labor-intensive and time-consuming manual reading, but its accuracy has not been sufficiently discussed to date. METHODS:1,423 test results obtained from manual reading using a microscope and an ELISPOT plate imager were compared. The agreement of qualitative test results was assessed using Cohen's kappa coefficient. The relationship of spot counts was studied using Bland-Altman analysis. RESULTS:The overall percent agreement of the qualitative test results was 95.43% with a kappa coefficient of 0.91. Positive test results with the maximum net spot count of 8 and borderline test results showed relatively high discordance. The agreement of spot counts in panel A, panel B, and nil control was good, and variability did not increase with higher spot counts. On the basis of study findings, a novel strategy for interpreting the test results by an ELISPOT plate imager was proposed. CONCLUSIONS:To increase diagnostic accuracy, positive test results with the maximum net spot count of 8 and borderline test results should be manually confirmed. Our strategy could be a practical guide for laboratories to build their own strategies for interpreting the test results by an ELISPOT plate imager.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0222920
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Tae Yeul Kim
Ho Eun Chang
Seong-Wook Lee
Soo Hyun Seo
Yun Ji Hong
Jeong Su Park
Kyoung Un Park
spellingShingle Tae Yeul Kim
Ho Eun Chang
Seong-Wook Lee
Soo Hyun Seo
Yun Ji Hong
Jeong Su Park
Kyoung Un Park
A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.
PLoS ONE
author_facet Tae Yeul Kim
Ho Eun Chang
Seong-Wook Lee
Soo Hyun Seo
Yun Ji Hong
Jeong Su Park
Kyoung Un Park
author_sort Tae Yeul Kim
title A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.
title_short A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.
title_full A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.
title_fullStr A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.
title_full_unstemmed A novel strategy for interpreting the T-SPOT.TB test results read by an ELISPOT plate imager.
title_sort novel strategy for interpreting the t-spot.tb test results read by an elispot plate imager.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS ONE
issn 1932-6203
publishDate 2019-01-01
description BACKGROUND:The T-SPOT.TB can be read by an ELISPOT plate imager as an alternative to a labor-intensive and time-consuming manual reading, but its accuracy has not been sufficiently discussed to date. METHODS:1,423 test results obtained from manual reading using a microscope and an ELISPOT plate imager were compared. The agreement of qualitative test results was assessed using Cohen's kappa coefficient. The relationship of spot counts was studied using Bland-Altman analysis. RESULTS:The overall percent agreement of the qualitative test results was 95.43% with a kappa coefficient of 0.91. Positive test results with the maximum net spot count of 8 and borderline test results showed relatively high discordance. The agreement of spot counts in panel A, panel B, and nil control was good, and variability did not increase with higher spot counts. On the basis of study findings, a novel strategy for interpreting the test results by an ELISPOT plate imager was proposed. CONCLUSIONS:To increase diagnostic accuracy, positive test results with the maximum net spot count of 8 and borderline test results should be manually confirmed. Our strategy could be a practical guide for laboratories to build their own strategies for interpreting the test results by an ELISPOT plate imager.
url https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0222920
work_keys_str_mv AT taeyeulkim anovelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT hoeunchang anovelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT seongwooklee anovelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT soohyunseo anovelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT yunjihong anovelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT jeongsupark anovelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT kyoungunpark anovelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT taeyeulkim novelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT hoeunchang novelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT seongwooklee novelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT soohyunseo novelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT yunjihong novelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT jeongsupark novelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
AT kyoungunpark novelstrategyforinterpretingthetspottbtestresultsreadbyanelispotplateimager
_version_ 1714818623603736576