Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head Injury

Background: The burden of traumatic brain injury (TBI) is rising in developing countries. Minor head injuries accounts for majority of non-fatal head injury and is associated with significant resource use. The utility of the CT scan in cases of mild head injury is undetermined although a big proport...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Abdalla RO, Qureshi MM, Saidi H, Abdallah A
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Surgical Society of Kenya 2015-01-01
Series:The Annals of African Surgery
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.annalsofafricansurgery.com/introduction-of-the-canadian-ct-hea
id doaj-08d5dedb07594fb0bdf3012c8754861c
record_format Article
spelling doaj-08d5dedb07594fb0bdf3012c8754861c2020-11-25T01:36:22ZengSurgical Society of Kenya The Annals of African Surgery1999-96742523-08162015-01-01121Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head InjuryAbdalla RO0Qureshi MM1Saidi H2Abdallah A3Aga Khan University HospitalAga Khan University HospitalAga Khan University HospitalAga Khan University HospitalBackground: The burden of traumatic brain injury (TBI) is rising in developing countries. Minor head injuries accounts for majority of non-fatal head injury and is associated with significant resource use. The utility of the CT scan in cases of mild head injury is undetermined although a big proportion of our patients are offered the investigation. We hypothesized that the introduction of the Canadian CT head rule (CCTHR) will reduce the utilization rate. Methods: Eighty four eligible patients diagnosed with minor head injury were recruited at the Accident and Emergency Department. The proportion of CT scan orders before (Group I-42 patients) and after (Group II- 42 patients) the introduction of the CCTHR was determined. Treatment in Group I patients followed the primary physician orders while group II patients were offered CT scans only if they presented with ‘high risk’ features of the CCTHR. Group II patients with ‘moderate’ risk factors were admitted for observation or discharged as appropriate to the rule. Results: The proportion of CT scans ordered in Group I was 95.2% while that in Group II was 21.4%. The proportion of patients with moderate risk factors Group I was 90.5%, representing the proportion of patients who did not require a CT scan. None of the patients required neurosurgical intervention and all had good recovery on follow up. Conclusion: The proportion of mild head injury patients requiring a CT scan at AKUH is 21.4%. Limiting CT scans to only this group was not associated with adverse outcomes. It is the recommended that CT scan rates for mild head injury be capped at 25% to save time and money currently being expended.https://www.annalsofafricansurgery.com/introduction-of-the-canadian-ct-heacanadian ct head ruleminor head injuryoutcomes
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Abdalla RO
Qureshi MM
Saidi H
Abdallah A
spellingShingle Abdalla RO
Qureshi MM
Saidi H
Abdallah A
Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head Injury
The Annals of African Surgery
canadian ct head rule
minor head injury
outcomes
author_facet Abdalla RO
Qureshi MM
Saidi H
Abdallah A
author_sort Abdalla RO
title Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head Injury
title_short Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head Injury
title_full Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head Injury
title_fullStr Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head Injury
title_full_unstemmed Introduction of the Canadian CT Head Rule Reduces CT Scan Use in Minor Head Injury
title_sort introduction of the canadian ct head rule reduces ct scan use in minor head injury
publisher Surgical Society of Kenya
series The Annals of African Surgery
issn 1999-9674
2523-0816
publishDate 2015-01-01
description Background: The burden of traumatic brain injury (TBI) is rising in developing countries. Minor head injuries accounts for majority of non-fatal head injury and is associated with significant resource use. The utility of the CT scan in cases of mild head injury is undetermined although a big proportion of our patients are offered the investigation. We hypothesized that the introduction of the Canadian CT head rule (CCTHR) will reduce the utilization rate. Methods: Eighty four eligible patients diagnosed with minor head injury were recruited at the Accident and Emergency Department. The proportion of CT scan orders before (Group I-42 patients) and after (Group II- 42 patients) the introduction of the CCTHR was determined. Treatment in Group I patients followed the primary physician orders while group II patients were offered CT scans only if they presented with ‘high risk’ features of the CCTHR. Group II patients with ‘moderate’ risk factors were admitted for observation or discharged as appropriate to the rule. Results: The proportion of CT scans ordered in Group I was 95.2% while that in Group II was 21.4%. The proportion of patients with moderate risk factors Group I was 90.5%, representing the proportion of patients who did not require a CT scan. None of the patients required neurosurgical intervention and all had good recovery on follow up. Conclusion: The proportion of mild head injury patients requiring a CT scan at AKUH is 21.4%. Limiting CT scans to only this group was not associated with adverse outcomes. It is the recommended that CT scan rates for mild head injury be capped at 25% to save time and money currently being expended.
topic canadian ct head rule
minor head injury
outcomes
url https://www.annalsofafricansurgery.com/introduction-of-the-canadian-ct-hea
work_keys_str_mv AT abdallaro introductionofthecanadianctheadrulereducesctscanuseinminorheadinjury
AT qureshimm introductionofthecanadianctheadrulereducesctscanuseinminorheadinjury
AT saidih introductionofthecanadianctheadrulereducesctscanuseinminorheadinjury
AT abdallaha introductionofthecanadianctheadrulereducesctscanuseinminorheadinjury
_version_ 1725063479078944768