'The Advisor': Counsel, Concealment, and Machiavelli’s Voice

• Main Author: Rob Goodman
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Helsinki University Press 2017-09-01
• Series: Redescriptions
• Subjects: machiavelli; cicero; rhetoric; advice; flattery; framing; rhetorical redescription; “mirrors for princes”
• Online Access: https://journal-redescriptions.org/articles/35

Machiavelli’s political works should be read not only as attempts to shape princely behavior, but as demonstrations of a model of advisory behavior. They are a performance of advice-giving, of the dispassionate, scientistic – but also quietly radical – behavior Machiavelli expects of those tasked with speaking to power. This model’s central feature is concealment of argument and rhetorical intent, a feature inherited from classical rhetoric but put to newly expansive use. This article turns from Machiavelli’s appropriation of the “mirror” literature’s concept of flattery, a kind of counter-ideal of advisory behavior, to his development of the classical rhetoric of self-effacement. It argues that he puts this rhetorical tradition to newly expansive use – not as a proto-scientist of politics but as a dynamic political actor in his own right – inventing ostensibly neutral dilemmas, classifications, and frames to guide the ruler-reader, as if voluntarily, toward some of his most distinctive conclusions.